
Nobody now alive signed the agreement that lets their government tax them, try them in court or send them to war. Yet for more than three centuries some of the sharpest minds in Europe and beyond have argued that legitimate power rests on exactly such an agreement, whether real, implied or imagined. The idea armed English soldiers arguing in a church at Putney, provoked a Scottish skeptic into writing one of his wittiest essays, and gave women and colonized peoples a standard by which to accuse the very men who had invented it.
Hobbes's terrifying sovereign, Locke's trust that rulers can forfeit, Rousseau's demanding general will and the modern revivals of Rawls, Scanlon and Gauthier each answer the same question differently: what would free and equal people have reason to accept? Along the way come Hume's doubts, the prisoner and the stag hunt, and the critics who asked who was left out. By the end, any claim that the people have agreed to something turns out to hide three questions: agreed how, which people, and agreed to what exactly.
CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia