
In November 1922 the United States Supreme Court told Takao Ozawa that he could not become a citizen because he was not Caucasian. Three months later it told Bhagat Singh Thind, whom many scientists of the day did call Caucasian, that he could not become a citizen either, because ordinary people would not call him white. If the highest court in the land could not keep its own definition steady for a single winter, what exactly is a race?
Philosophers have given startlingly different answers: a pattern written in the genome, a social position made by law and habit, a shared history worth preserving, or an illusion we should finally let go. From Du Bois and Fanon to Charles Mills and Glenn Loury, each thinker here gets to make the strongest version of the case and then faces the strongest reply. What you gain is a sharper ear. In any argument about census forms, medicine or college admissions, you can learn to hear which picture of race the speaker is quietly relying on, and to ask whether it can bear the weight being put on it.
CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia