Skip to main content

People have always noticed that strangers look, speak and live differently. The idea that humanity divides into a few natural kinds, each with fixed inner qualities passed down by descent, is something more specific, and philosophers of race begin by asking where it came from. Their answer shapes everything else, because a concept with a history can be examined, revised or even retired.

Before race

Ancient Greek writers noticed skin color and customs, but they usually explained differences by place rather than lineage. The Hippocratic treatise Airs, Waters, Places claimed that climate shaped bodies and temperaments, so that harsh or mild lands produced hardy or soft peoples. Frank Snowden, a historian of the ancient Mediterranean, argued that Greeks and Romans showed no color prejudice of the modern kind, and that Ethiopians appear in their art and writing without a fixed rank. Benjamin Isaac replied in 2004 that the ancients held a "proto-racism" tied to place and climate: they believed groups inherited fixed traits from their environment and used that belief to justify conquest. The disagreement is real, but both sides agree that the modern system of color-coded continental races had not yet been built.

Blood and lineage

One early step came in Spain. After mass conversions of Jews to Christianity, a statute passed in Toledo in 1449 barred converts and their descendants from public office. Later "purity of blood" rules spread to guilds, religious orders and universities. What mattered was no longer a person's faith, which could change, but ancestry, which could not. Historians debate how far this was racial thinking, yet it shows the move from belief to blood that later systems would generalize.

Naturalists sort humanity

In 1684 the French physician and traveler François Bernier published, anonymously, one of the first attempts to divide all of humanity into a handful of "species or races" by body type and region. The Swedish naturalist Carl Linnaeus went further. In the 1758 edition of his Systema Naturae, Linnaeus attached temperaments and forms of government to each of four continental varieties, describing Europeans as ruled by laws and Africans as ruled by caprice. Johann Friedrich Blumenbach, a German anatomist, proposed five varieties, and in 1795 Blumenbach coined the label "Caucasian", after the Caucasus mountains, because he judged a skull from Georgia the most beautiful in his collection. Blumenbach himself insisted that the varieties shaded into one another and that no sharp line could be drawn, a caution later writers dropped.

Philosophers join in

Immanuel Kant wrote essays on race from 1775 onward and defined races as lineages whose traits are reliably inherited when groups mix. The philosopher Robert Bernasconi has argued that Kant gave the first scientific definition of race, and that Kant ranked the races in his lectures on geography. Thomas Jefferson, in his Notes on the State of Virginia (1785), wrote: "I advance it therefore as a suspicion only, that the blacks, whether originally a distinct race, or made distinct by time and circumstances, are inferior to the whites in the endowments both of body and mind." The wording matters: Jefferson presented Black inferiority as a suspicion, not a proven fact, even as he enslaved more than six hundred people over his life.

Why invent race?

Why did this system harden in the age of the Atlantic slave trade? The historian Barbara Fields argued that racial ideology arose to explain slavery in a society that preached liberty. If all men are created equal, holding some in bondage needs an excuse, and a doctrine that they are a lesser kind supplies it. On this reading, slavery did not grow out of race; race grew out of slavery. Critics answer that prejudice against dark skin and against outsiders is older than the plantation economy, and that the ideology then took on a life of its own. Many scholars hold a middle view: older prejudices existed, but the modern idea of race was assembled in a specific period for specific uses.

None of this settles whether races exist. A concept can arise for bad reasons and still pick out something real, as chemistry grew out of alchemy. But it explains why philosophers treat the word with care and why the next questions are about biology.

Worked example: reading Jefferson

Take Jefferson's sentence slowly. First, notice the hedge: "a suspicion only." He knew his evidence was thin, and elsewhere in the same work he admitted that Black Americans had never been given the chance to show their abilities under fair conditions. Second, notice the phrase "whether originally a distinct race, or made distinct by time and circumstances." He leaves open whether the difference is inborn or produced by history, yet draws a firm conclusion anyway. Third, ask what the claim did. It appeared in a book that also condemned slavery as a moral evil, and it helped reconcile that condemnation with a refusal to free people or imagine them as fellow citizens. A careful reader can hold three things at once: Jefferson saw the injustice, he doubted his own evidence, and he still offered a theory of inferiority that served his interests. That combination, a weak claim doing heavy social work, is exactly what Fields and others point to when they call race an ideology.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did Frank Snowden argue about ancient Greeks and Romans?
2. What did Benjamin Isaac claim the ancients held?
3. What did the Toledo statute of 1449 do?
4. What did Bernier publish in 1684?
5. What did Linnaeus add to his human varieties in 1758?
6. Who coined the label Caucasian in 1795?
7. How did Jefferson present Black inferiority in his Notes?
8. What did Barbara Fields argue racial ideology arose to do?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia