Skip to main content

If races are not natural kinds, are they unreal? Social constructionists say no. Money, borders and marriage are made by human practices, and they are as real as anything in daily life. A dollar bill is just paper, but try telling that to a landlord. Constructionists hold that race is real in this way: made, not found, yet powerful.

Making races

The sociologists Michael Omi and Howard Winant gave this idea an influential form in 1986. By "racial formation" they meant the historical process by which racial categories are created, lived, changed and destroyed through law, politics, culture and everyday encounters. Who counts as white or Black, and what that means, has been argued over and revised for centuries. Census forms are a simple record of this: American censuses have added, merged and dropped categories many times.

Haslanger's definition

The philosopher Sally Haslanger offered a sharp definition in 2000. Roughly, a group is racialized when its members are marked by real or imagined bodily features linked to an ancestral region, and are thereby placed in a position of privilege or subordination. On this view, race is a social position, like being a landlord or a tenant, not a biological property. Haslanger also changed the question. Instead of asking only what people mean by race, her "ameliorative" approach asks which concept of race would best serve the goal of justice. If our purpose is to understand and fight racial injustice, she argues, we need a concept that puts hierarchy at its center.

Looping effects

The philosopher Ian Hacking pointed to a feature that sets human kinds apart from rocks or stars. When people are classified, they learn of the classification and respond to it. Hacking called this a "looping effect": people change in response to the categories applied to them, which in turn changes the categories. A label imposed as a mark of shame can become a banner of pride, and its meaning shifts as a result. Racial categories loop constantly, which is one reason constructionists say they cannot be fixed by biology.

Who became white

Historians have traced how groups moved in and out of whiteness. Some argued that Irish, Italian and Jewish immigrants to America were once seen as not fully white and later "became" white. Other historians criticize this story as exaggerated, noting that these immigrants could naturalize and vote as white men under the law from the start. The debate itself illustrates the constructionist claim: the boundaries of a race are the kind of thing that can be argued over in archives.

Who counts as white in law

From 1790 American naturalization law limited citizenship to "free white persons," later adding people of African descent. Two cases in the 1920s show the construction at work. Takao Ozawa, born in Japan, had lived in the United States for two decades, attended the University of California, and argued that his light skin made him white. In 1922 the Supreme Court ruled that "white" meant Caucasian and that Ozawa was not Caucasian. Bhagat Singh Thind, an Indian Sikh who had served in the American army, then argued that leading anthropologists of the day classified people of northern India as Caucasian. Three months after Ozawa, in 1923 the Court ruled that Thind was not white in the common understanding of the word. Justice George Sutherland, writing both opinions, said the words "free white persons" are "words of common speech, to be interpreted in accordance with the understanding of the common man." After Thind, the government moved to strip citizenship from some Indian Americans who had already naturalized. Consider what the Court did. When science seemed to exclude, it relied on science. When science seemed to include, it switched to popular opinion. Constructionists see a racial line being drawn by law to reach a result, with whatever justification lay at hand.

Criticisms

Constructionism faces challenges from several sides. Biological realists say it ignores the genetic structure discussed earlier. Some critics of Haslanger's definition object that if race simply is a place in a hierarchy, then a Black person who escapes subordination would stop being Black, and a proud racial identity becomes hard to describe. Others worry that the ameliorative approach mixes up what a word means with what we wish it meant. The philosopher Ron Mallon has argued that many sides in the race debate agree on the facts and differ mainly over which words to use and what to do, so the real disputes are moral and political rather than metaphysical.

Worked example: a label that looped

In the 1960s, people of Chinese, Japanese, Filipino and Korean descent in the United States were often lumped together by outsiders under the term "Oriental," and many of them saw little in common with one another. In 1968 student activists in Berkeley founded an organization under the name "Asian American," choosing a label for themselves that stressed shared treatment and shared political goals. Within a generation the term appeared on government forms, in university departments and in everyday speech. Apply the ideas of this level. Haslanger would ask whether the group is marked by perceived bodily features tied to a region and positioned by them, and much of the evidence of the era, from exclusion laws to the wartime internment of Japanese Americans, says yes. Hacking would point to the loop: an outside category was taken up, renamed and turned to new purposes by the people it described, and the category changed as a result. Today some members of the group argue that it hides huge differences in income and history, for example between the descendants of Japanese immigrants and recent refugees from Laos, which is the loop turning again. A realist about biological race has little to say about any of this, because the label never tracked a single genetic population to begin with.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did Omi and Winant mean by racial formation?
2. On Haslanger's definition, what makes a group racialized?
3. What does Haslanger's ameliorative approach ask?
4. What did Ian Hacking mean by a looping effect?
5. What did Ron Mallon argue about the race debate?
6. Why did the Supreme Court rule against Ozawa in 1922?
7. On what ground did the Court rule against Thind in 1923?
8. What did Justice Sutherland call the words free white persons?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia