Skip to main content

Anti-realists about biological race do not deny that people differ or that ancestry leaves traces in DNA. They deny that those differences come packaged into a few natural groups that match the races of ordinary talk. Their case has several strands, and each meets a reply.

Clines

In 1962 the anthropologist Frank Livingstone argued that human variation changes gradually across space rather than in steps. A cline is a gradual change in a trait across a geographic range, like the slow shift in average skin tone as one travels from the equator toward the poles. Walk from Nigeria to Norway, village by village, and at no point do you cross a line where one race ends and another begins. Livingstone concluded that the term race should be dropped in favor of describing clines. In 2004 the geneticists David Serre and Svante Pääbo found that when people are sampled evenly across geography, sharp clusters tend to give way to gradients. Gaps between clusters, they suggested, partly reflect gaps in the sampling.

Traits that do not line up

A second strand is discordance. If races were natural kinds, their markers should travel together. Instead, different traits draw different maps. Skin color tracks the strength of ultraviolet sunlight, not overall ancestry, which is why Indigenous Australians and many sub-Saharan Africans both have dark skin despite tens of thousands of years of separate descent. Lactose tolerance draws one map, blood types another. Sickle cell trait is often called a "Black disease," yet sickle cell trait follows the historical range of malaria, so it is also common in parts of Greece, the Arabian Peninsula and India and rare among Africans from regions without malaria.

Africa and the rest

A third strand comes from human history. Modern humans arose in Africa, and the people who left it carried only part of its genetic variety. Africa holds more human genetic diversity than any other continent, and much of the variation found elsewhere is a subset of what exists there. Two people from different parts of Africa can differ genetically more than either differs from a person in Europe. A scheme that places all Africans in one race and splits Eurasia into several gets the shape of the human family tree backward.

Folk races change at the border

The final strand compares scientific groups with the categories people actually use. In the United States, the one-drop rule, known to scholars as hypodescent, assigned anyone with known African ancestry to the Black group. Homer Plessy, whose challenge to segregated rail cars reached the Supreme Court in 1896, was described as seven-eighths white, yet Louisiana counted him as colored. In Brazil, classification has long followed appearance more than ancestry, and siblings can be placed in different categories. A 1976 Brazilian household survey that let people describe their own color recorded 136 different terms. The philosopher Naomi Zack argued that since no biological fact matches these shifting folk lines, the folk races are not biological kinds.

The realist's reply

Realists answer each strand. Gradients do not erase categories: the color spectrum is continuous, yet red and blue are real. Discordant traits matter less than overall ancestry, which is exactly what genome-wide clustering measures. And the mismatch with folk categories shows only that ordinary usage is messy, not that nothing real lies underneath. Some anti-realists concede part of this. They accept that continental ancestry groups can be detected, but argue that calling them "races" drags in the old racialist baggage and invites misuse.

Why the answer matters, and why it does not

Much of nineteenth century race science was built to show that some people were less than fully human, and its errors were used to defend slavery, colonial rule and forced sterilization. It matters, then, that the old picture of sharply bounded, ranked races is false. But it is worth being clear about the logic. Equal human worth does not depend on how genes are distributed. If tomorrow's research found sharper population boundaries than today's, no one would become less entitled to rights. Both realists and anti-realists can agree on this, which lets the scientific debate proceed honestly rather than as a proxy for moral battles.

Worked example: one person, three passports

Imagine a woman named Lucia. Her mother's parents came from Angola; her father's family has lived in Portugal and Brazil for generations, with ancestors from Europe, Africa and the Indigenous Americas. In Atlanta, under the old one-drop habit, people would likely call her Black. In Salvador, Brazil, she might be described as morena or parda, a mixed category that depends on her shade and hair. In Lisbon, she might be seen first as Brazilian. Her genome has not changed on any of these flights. A genetic ancestry test would report percentages from several continents, an answer that fits none of the three local labels exactly. The anti-realist draws the lesson that the race assigned to Lucia is a fact about each society's rules, not about her body. The realist agrees about the labels but points out that the ancestry test itself found real structure. The disagreement, on inspection, is about whether that structure deserves the name "race."

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What is a cline?
2. What did Serre and Pääbo find in 2004?
3. What does discordance mean in the anti-realist case?
4. What does sickle cell trait follow?
5. Why, say anti-realists, does one African race get the family tree backward?
6. How was Homer Plessy described in his 1896 case?
7. How many color terms did a 1976 Brazilian survey record?
8. What did Naomi Zack conclude about folk races?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia