From seminar to movement
By the late 1980s the academic debate had found a public voice. Its main organizer was Amitai Etzioni, a sociologist born in Germany in 1929, who fled the Nazis as a child, fought in Israel's war of independence, and later taught at Columbia and George Washington University. Etzioni thought the philosophical quarrel had practical stakes. American public life, he argued, had become lopsided: rich in claims of rights, thin in talk of responsibilities.
In 1991 Etzioni and a group of scholars issued the Responsive Communitarian Platform. They chose the word responsive to set themselves apart from authoritarian communitarians, who would sacrifice individual rights to tradition. Their aim was balance: strong rights, matched by strong responsibilities to family, neighborhood and nation.
The new golden rule
Etzioni compressed his view into a slogan he called the new golden rule. It asks people to uphold society's moral order as they would have society respect their autonomy. Neither autonomy nor social order should swallow the other. A society with too much order becomes oppressive; one with too little falls into isolation and disorder.
How should order be kept without the state doing everything? Etzioni's answer was the moral voice: informal approval and disapproval from the people around us. Friends, neighbors and colleagues who express disapproval of a drunk driver or an absent parent can do what laws cannot, and with less coercion. He also suggested a pause on announcing new rights, worrying that turning every want into a right cheapened the language of rights for the claims that matter most.
Rights talk
The legal scholar Mary Ann Glendon, who signed the platform, made a related argument in Rights Talk (1991). She criticized absolute rights language that says little of duties. American political debate, she argued, tended to frame every question as a clash of rights stated in all-or-nothing terms, leaving no words for responsibility, sociability or compromise. She compared this with other democracies whose constitutions paired rights with duties and limits.
Habits of the heart
A sociological study gave the movement much of its texture. In Habits of the Heart (1985), Robert Bellah and four colleagues interviewed middle-class Americans about what gave their lives meaning. The title came from Alexis de Tocqueville, who had used the phrase "habits of the heart" for the mores that sustain a free people.
The researchers found that their subjects' first language was individualism. People explained their choices in terms of self-fulfilment and personal preference, even when they were deeply committed to others. One woman, a nurse they called Sheila, described a faith of her own that she named after herself. Bellah's team used Sheilaism for a private faith built and held by one person alone. But the interviews also revealed second languages of commitment Americans still use: the biblical and civic republican traditions, in which people spoke of covenant, service and the common good. The authors hoped these second languages could be strengthened. The book became a surprise bestseller and gave the movement a vocabulary for what it thought was missing.
The movement drew politicians as well as scholars. Its language of rights matched by responsibilities appeared in speeches by Bill Clinton in the United States and Tony Blair in Britain, whose Third Way sought a path between the old left and the new right. Supporters saw this as proof that the ideas could travel. Critics saw a slogan that each politician filled with whatever duties suited him, often duties for the poor, such as work requirements for welfare, rather than for the powerful.
Critics of the movement
Critics were not persuaded. Majorities can use social pressure to silence minorities, and the moral voice that shames a drunk driver can also shame a gay teenager or an unmarried mother. Whose moral order, critics asked, is being upheld? Etzioni answered that community values must themselves pass the test of basic rights and that the moral voice should be open to argument. Others found the movement vague: it praised community in general while avoiding the hard question of what to do when communities clash.
Worked example: stopping drivers on the highway
In 1990 the US Supreme Court, in Michigan Department of State Police v. Sitz, upheld roadside sobriety checkpoints at which police briefly stop every car to look for signs of drunk driving, without suspicion of any particular driver. Civil liberties groups opposed the practice as a search without cause. Etzioni defended it.
His reasoning shows the communitarian balance at work. The intrusion is brief, applies to everyone equally, and serves a serious shared good: thousands of lives lost each year to drunk driving. A purely rights-based view, he argued, would protect each driver's privacy while ignoring the community's interest in safe roads. A liberal critic would reply that small, universal intrusions add up, and that rights exist precisely to resist appeals to the common good. The case shows that the dispute is often about where to draw a line, not about whether rights or community matter.
