Justice from the inside
Michael Walzer, an American political theorist long associated with the magazine Dissent, took a different route from the other critics. He did not attack Rawls's picture of the self so much as his method. In Spheres of Justice (1983) Walzer argued that philosophers should not try to step outside every society, as the original position does, and design principles from nowhere. Justice is better found by interpreting the meanings that goods already have for the people who make and share them.
Goods and their meanings
Walzer's central claim is that goods are social. Bread, office, education, medical care, honor and love all mean something to the people who use them, and those meanings carry criteria for distribution. The shared social meaning of a good should decide how it is distributed. If medical care is understood as a response to need, it should go to the sick according to need, not to the rich according to wealth. If a prize means recognition of excellence, it cannot be bought without ceasing to be a prize. Walzer insisted that no single criterion, whether need, desert or free exchange, fits every good. Each has its proper sphere, and trouble starts when one of them is stretched to cover everything, as when a market society treats even honor as something for sale.
Dominance and monopoly
Walzer distinguishes two problems. A monopoly exists when one group controls a good. A good is dominant when holding it lets people command many other goods. Money is the obvious dominant good in modern societies, but in other times birth, land, religious standing or party membership played that role.
Most egalitarians, Walzer says, attack monopoly: they want the dominant good spread more evenly. He calls that simple equality and thinks it is unstable, since new inequalities appear as soon as people use their shares. He proposes instead complex equality: keeping advantage in one sphere from ruling the others. Some people will be richer, some more honored, some more powerful. What matters is that wealth does not buy office, that office does not buy love, that birth does not buy education.
He borrowed the core idea from Blaise Pascal, who wrote in the seventeenth century: "Tyranny consists in the desire of universal power beyond its scope." For Walzer, tyranny is seeking power beyond one's own sphere, the strong demanding to be loved, the rich demanding to rule.
Blocked exchanges
One practical result is a list of blocked exchanges. A blocked exchange is a trade that money should not be able to make. In a modern democracy, Walzer argued, you cannot legitimately buy votes, verdicts, public office, freedom of speech, exemption from jury duty or military service, a marriage license or a person. Markets are fine in their own sphere; the trouble begins when they spill out of it.
Thick and thin
The obvious objection is relativism. If justice depends on shared meanings, what about a caste society whose members largely accept caste? Walzer conceded that his approach must take such societies seriously, which troubled many readers. Ronald Dworkin objected that societies rarely share one meaning for contested goods: Americans argue about whether health care is a right or a commodity, and that argument is exactly what a theory of justice must settle, not assume.
Walzer replied in later work. In Thick and Thin (1994) he described two layers of morality. Thin morality is a minimal core of moral rules shared across cultures: prohibitions on murder, deception, gross cruelty and tyranny. Thick morality is the dense local detail that gives these rules life in a particular place. People in different societies can recognize one another's struggles against tyranny without sharing every value.
He also defended a style of criticism. The connected critic argues from within a society's own values, holding the society to its professed ideals, as the Hebrew prophets reproached Israel in the name of its own covenant. Walzer thought this kind of critic more effective and more honest than one who claims a view from nowhere.
Worked example: buying your way out of a war
In March 1863, during the American Civil War, the Union passed a conscription law. A drafted man could avoid service by hiring a substitute or paying a commutation fee of three hundred dollars, about a year's wages for a laborer. In July that year riots broke out in New York City, partly over this rule. "A rich man's war and a poor man's fight" became a common complaint, and Congress ended commutation for most draftees the next year.
Walzer's idea of blocked exchanges explains what went wrong. The burden of military service in a democracy belongs to the sphere of citizenship and is meant to fall on citizens as equals. Letting money buy exemption allowed dominance in the market to cross into a sphere where it did not belong. A simple egalitarian might respond by giving everyone three hundred dollars; Walzer's point is that the exchange itself was wrong, whatever the distribution of cash.
