Skip to main content

Jeremy Bentham was born in London in 1748, read Latin as a small child and entered Oxford at twelve. His father expected him to become a great lawyer. Instead, Bentham came away from his legal training appalled. English law, he thought, was a tangle of fictions, delays and fees that served lawyers and judges far better than the public.

Against Blackstone

As a student, Bentham heard the lectures of William Blackstone, whose Commentaries on the Laws of England presented the common law as a near perfect system. In A Fragment on Government (1776), Bentham attacked William Blackstone, accusing him of dressing up existing law as natural and wise when much of it was neither. Bentham wanted to distinguish two questions that Blackstone ran together: what the law is, and what it ought to be. The second question, he insisted, had one answer: the law ought to be whatever best promotes the happiness of the community.

His Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation, printed in 1780 and published in 1789, set this out as a science of law. Pleasures and pains could be weighed by their intensity, duration and certainty, and by their extent, the number of people affected. Lawmakers should use the results to design rewards and penalties.

Punishment as a necessary evil

Bentham's theory of punishment is among his most lasting contributions. "All punishment is mischief," he wrote, "all punishment in itself is evil." Punishment causes pain to the person punished, worry to his family and cost to the state. So Bentham held that punishment is itself an evil, justified only when it prevents a greater evil. Revenge and moral outrage are not reasons in themselves.

He listed cases in which punishment should not be inflicted at all. It is groundless where no real harm was done, as when the supposed victim consented. It is unprofitable where the pain of punishment would exceed the harm it prevents, and needless where the harm could be stopped more cheaply, for example by teaching. And punishment is inefficacious, and so wrong, when it cannot deter, as with a law made after the act or an offender unable to understand it. These tests made Bentham a critic of the many capital crimes on England's books, and a voice for punishment that fits the harm.

Rights and nonsense

Bentham was no friend to the language of natural rights. When the French revolutionaries issued their Declaration of the Rights of Man, he wrote a long critique, later published as Anarchical Fallacies. "Natural rights is simple nonsense," he declared, "natural and imprescriptible rights, rhetorical nonsense, nonsense upon stilts." He feared that rights claimed to be beyond all law would encourage people to resist any government they disliked.

For Bentham, a real right exists only where a law, backed by a government, creates it. Rights are valuable, and he wanted many more of them, but they are tools made by law for the sake of happiness, not facts about human nature.

Words and codes

Bentham invented words as readily as laws. He coined the word "international" in the Introduction, to name the law between nations, and he popularized "codification" for his lifelong dream: replacing scattered judge-made law with clear written codes anyone could read.

Sinister interests

Bentham began by hoping that wise rulers would adopt his reforms once they saw the arguments. Years of polite refusals changed his mind. He concluded that rulers pursue their own "sinister interests" unless voters can hold them to account. From about 1809 he became a democrat, arguing for a secret ballot, frequent elections and a much wider vote. In his Plan of Parliamentary Reform (1817) he made the case to a nation that still let only a small minority of men vote.

A last demonstration

Bentham died on 6 June 1832, the day before the Great Reform Act became law. True to his principles, he directed that his body be publicly dissected for medical teaching, then preserved and displayed as an "auto-icon". At the time surgeons were short of bodies to study, and Bentham wanted to show that a corpse could do good. His skeleton, dressed in his own clothes and topped with a wax head, still sits in a glass case at University College London.

Worked example: jail for street vending?

A city council proposes jail terms of up to six months for selling food on the street without a license. Bentham would run the proposal through his tests. Is there real harm? Some, perhaps: unlicensed food can make people sick, and vendors may block pavements. So the law is not groundless. Would it deter? Many vendors are poor migrants who may not know the law, which weakens deterrence. Is it profitable? Jail costs the city heavily, cuts off a family's income and may turn a small trader into an unemployable ex-prisoner, which looks far worse than the harm prevented. Is it needless? Cheap food safety classes and an easier licensing process might solve most of the problem.

On Bentham's reasoning the jail proposal fails, not because vendors have a natural right to sell, but because it adds more misery than it removes. A small fine, combined with help getting licensed, would pass his tests far more easily.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Whom did Bentham attack in A Fragment on Government (1776)?
2. How did Bentham regard punishment in itself?
3. When did Bentham call punishment inefficacious?
4. What did Bentham call natural and imprescriptible rights?
5. Where, for Bentham, do real rights come from?
6. Which word did Bentham coin?
7. Why did Bentham come to favor democracy?
8. What did Bentham ask to be done with his body?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia