In Charles Dickens's David Copperfield (1850), the cheerful and perpetually broke Mr. Micawber offers a famous lesson: "Annual income twenty pounds, annual expenditure nineteen nineteen and six, result happiness. Annual income twenty pounds, annual expenditure twenty pounds ought and six, result misery." Micawber's lesson is that spending even slightly more than you earn leads to misery; a single shilling separates comfort from ruin. Modern households face the same arithmetic, with far more ways to borrow and far more complicated terms.
Kinds of debt
Household debts differ in ways that matter. A secured debt is backed by collateral that the lender can seize if payments stop: a mortgage is secured by the home, a car loan by the car. Because the lender can recover something, secured loans usually carry lower interest. An unsecured debt, such as most credit card balances and medical bills, has no such backing, so it usually costs more.
Debts also differ in shape. An installment loan has a fixed schedule of payments that ends on a set date. Revolving credit, like a credit card, lets a borrower borrow again up to a limit as they repay, with no fixed end. Revolving credit is flexible, which is both its strength and its danger.
The minimum payment trap
Credit card statements show a small minimum payment, often just a few percent of the balance. Paying only the minimum keeps the account in good standing, but most of each payment goes to interest. A balance of a few thousand at a typical card rate can take well over a decade to clear this way, and the total interest can rival the original debt. Since a 2009 United States law, card statements must show how long payoff would take paying only the minimum. Seeing "17 years" printed on a statement changes some people's behavior.
Credit scores
Lenders judge a stranger's reliability through credit reports and scores. In the United States the FICO score, introduced in 1989, became the standard. It ranges from 300 to 850, and payment history, whether bills were paid on time, is the largest single factor in a FICO score. How much of the available credit is in use comes next. Scores now affect not only loan rates but sometimes apartment rentals and insurance prices.
Credit reporting has real benefits. It lets a lender extend credit to someone with no personal connection, which was once nearly impossible for outsiders. But the reports are not always accurate. A Federal Trade Commission study released in 2013 found that about one in five consumers had an error on at least one credit report. People with thin files, often the young, recent immigrants and the poor, can find credit expensive or unavailable regardless of their character.
Credit also has a history of exclusion. Until the 1970s, American women were often refused credit cards or loans without a husband's signature, whatever their income. The Equal Credit Opportunity Act of 1974 barred lenders from discriminating on the basis of sex or marital status, and amendments soon added race, religion, national origin and age. Fair access to credit came to be seen as part of equal citizenship.
Good debt and bad debt
Financial advice often sorts debt into good and bad. On this view, good debt buys something that grows in value or raises earning power, such as education or a home, and bad debt pays for things used up quickly, such as holidays or dinners out. The distinction captures something true: borrowing to build capacity can pay for itself.
Critics argue the label misleads. Whether a debt is good depends on its price, its terms and whether the investment works out. A home can lose value. Student loans pay off well for most graduates, but borrowers who leave college without finishing a degree are especially likely to default on student loans, because they carry the debt without the higher earnings. A better question than "Is this good debt?" is "What happens to me if this goes wrong?"
Worked example: Leo's three debts
Leo, 29, owes money three ways: a car loan at 7 percent secured by his car, a student loan at 5 percent, and 4,000 on a credit card at 24 percent, on which he pays only the minimum. His statement says that at the minimum, the card will take 14 years to repay. He sorts his debts by interest rate. The card is unsecured, revolving and by far the costliest, so he directs every spare amount to it, paying only what is required on the other two. He also checks his credit reports, finds an old phone bill wrongly listed as unpaid, and disputes it. His score rises after the correction, and a lower-rate card becomes available to him. None of this required complex math, only knowing which kind of debt was which.
