Skip to main content

Most people know they should save more and borrow less, and many sincerely plan to start next month. Next month arrives and the plan moves to the month after. This is not simple ignorance or weakness. It reflects a pattern in how human minds weigh the present against the future, and it shapes nearly every decision about money.

Discounting the future

It is reasonable to value a reward now more than the same reward later. The future is uncertain, and money in hand can be used. Economists call this discounting. The puzzle is in its shape. If people discounted at a steady rate, waiting a week would feel the same whether the week started today or a year from now. Experiments show otherwise. Offered 100 today or 110 in a week, many people take the 100. Offered 100 in a year or 110 in a year and a week, most wait for the 110. The extra week is the same; only its distance from now has changed.

The psychiatrist George Ainslie and others found that people, and even pigeons, behave this way. Hyperbolic discounting means that people discount near delays steeply and distant delays only gently. The everyday name for the result is present bias: a tendency to overweight rewards and costs that arrive right now. Its signature is the preference reversal: a choice made calmly in advance flips when the moment of decision arrives. The economist David Laibson built models showing how a person with this bias will keep undoing their own savings plans, and why easy credit can make the problem worse.

Knowing yourself, or not

Researchers distinguish two kinds of present-biased people. A sophisticated person knows the pattern and plans around it. A naive person expects their future self to be more patient than they are now, and so makes plans that their future self will not follow. Naivety is costly in markets, because sellers can design products around it.

A well-known study of gyms showed how. The economists Stefano DellaVigna and Ulrike Malmendier studied members of American health clubs who chose monthly contracts. Gym members on monthly contracts paid more per visit than a pay-per-visit pass would have cost, because they went far less often than they expected when they signed up. Credit cards with low teaser rates, phone plans with cheap first months, and "buy now, pay later" offers often work on the same principle: the cost falls on a future self whom the buyer misjudges.

Designing around the bias

If the pull of now cannot be wished away, it can be worked with. Two famous designs show how. Around the turn of the century, studies of American workplace retirement plans found that when employers switched to enrolling new workers automatically, while letting them opt out, participation soared. Automatic enrollment raised retirement saving because doing nothing now meant saving. Inertia, usually the enemy of saving, became its ally.

The economists Richard Thaler and Shlomo Benartzi went further with a plan called Save More Tomorrow. Workers were invited to commit, in advance, a share of their future pay raises to savings. Because the cost lay in the future, it felt light; because it came out of raises, take-home pay never fell. Save More Tomorrow asked workers to commit future pay raises, not current pay, to saving. At the first company to try it, average savings rates among participants roughly quadrupled over about three and a half years.

Is impatience always irrational?

There is a fair challenge to the whole idea. Taking the money now is sometimes wise. A person whose landlord has been unreliable, whose job could vanish, or whose promised payments have failed before has good reason to distrust the future. In a 2013 study, children waited much longer for a second treat when the adult running the test had kept an earlier promise than when the adult had broken one. Impatience can be a rational response to an unreliable environment, not only a flaw in the person. This matters for fairness: before blaming people for short-term choices, it is worth asking whether their world has given them reason to trust the long term.

Worked example: Priya's bonus

Priya gets a bonus of 2,000 in December. In October she planned to put all of it toward her credit card balance. Now a sale on a new phone is pulling at her, and a voice says she can pay the card down next month. She recognizes a preference reversal: the October plan was made calmly, at a distance, and the December urge is the pull of now. Knowing her pattern, she acts like a sophisticated planner. She schedules the card payment for the day the bonus arrives, before browsing any shop, and arranges for 10 percent of every future raise to go into savings automatically. She still buys a cheaper phone, from money left over after the plan is carried out. The bias has not vanished, but her choices are now arranged so that doing nothing produces the result she wanted.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What does hyperbolic discounting mean?
2. What is present bias?
3. What happens in a preference reversal?
4. In this research, what does a naive present-biased person do?
5. What did the study of gym members on monthly contracts find?
6. Why did automatic enrollment raise retirement saving?
7. What did Save More Tomorrow ask workers to commit to saving?
8. When can impatience be a rational response, according to the level?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia