Skip to main content

The Spanish Inquisition followed Spain's empire, and it outlived the conversos of 1391 by centuries. Two forces kept it busy long after 1500: a new wave of suspected Judaizers from Portugal, and the spread of purity of blood rules that judged people by their ancestors.

Purity of blood

The Toledo decree of 1449 had been condemned, but the idea behind it spread. Colleges, religious orders, military orders, cathedral chapters and guilds adopted statutes requiring members to prove that they had no Jewish or Muslim ancestors, nor any ancestor condemned by the Inquisition. In 1547 Archbishop Juan Martínez Silíceo imposed such a statute on the cathedral chapter of Toledo, and Philip II confirmed it in 1556. Candidates had to submit genealogies, and investigators traveled to their family towns to question elderly witnesses. The process was expensive, open to bribery and malicious gossip, and could ruin a family's prospects for generations.

The statutes had critics within the Church. The Society of Jesus at first refused to adopt one, and its second superior general, Diego Laínez, came from a converso family. Under pressure, a Jesuit general congregation in 1593 barred men of Jewish or Muslim descent from entering the order. In 1599 the Dominican Agustín Salucio wrote a treatise arguing that the statutes divided the kingdom and should be softened. Around 1560 Cardinal Francisco Mendoza y Bobadilla, angered when a relative was refused entry to a military order, sent Philip II a memorial later known as the Tizón de la nobleza, which argued that many of Spain's greatest noble houses had Jewish ancestors. If the grandees themselves could not pass the test, he implied, the test was absurd. The debate shows Spaniards themselves recognizing the cost of a system that made baptism count for less than lineage.

The Portuguese New Christians

Many Jews expelled from Spain in 1492 went to Portugal, where in 1497 they were forced to convert. Portugal created its own Inquisition in 1536. When Philip II became king of Portugal in 1580, movement between the two kingdoms became easier, and many Portuguese New Christians, some of them wealthy bankers and merchants, settled in Spain. In the seventeenth century, most of those tried in Spain for Judaizing were of Portuguese origin. Trials of this kind continued into the eighteenth century. In 1691 a series of autos in Palma de Mallorca burned more than thirty people of converso descent, and their descendants, known as chuetas, faced discrimination there into the twentieth century.

Tribunals in the Americas

Philip II ordered tribunals for the Americas in 1569. The tribunal of Lima opened in 1570, Mexico City in 1571 and Cartagena de Indias in 1610. Before that, bishops had acted as inquisitors. The first bishop of Mexico, Juan de Zumárraga, had a Nahua noble, Don Carlos Ometochtzin of Texcoco, burned in 1539 for idolatry and for urging resistance to Christianity, and the crown disapproved of the execution. When the new tribunals were founded, Indigenous people were excluded from their jurisdiction, on the grounds that they were new to the faith; their religious offenses were left to bishops.

The American tribunals pursued Spaniards, people of African descent and others for blasphemy, bigamy, propositions, sorcery and Judaizing. Some of the most striking files concern enslaved Africans. In Mexico and Cartagena, enslaved people sometimes renounced God while being whipped, which forced the master to stop and brought the case before the Inquisition. Historians read these outbursts as a desperate strategy: the tribunal punished the blasphemer, but it could also reprimand a master for cruelty, so an outrage against heaven became a way to appeal against an earthly owner. In Mexico City Luis de Carvajal the younger, burned in 1596, left letters and a memoir describing his secret Jewish faith. In Lima, during what was called the great complicity, the tribunal arrested dozens of Portuguese merchants in 1635, and a great auto in 1639 burned the wealthy trader Manuel Bautista Pérez among others.

Worked example: proving a pedigree

Imagine a young man in 1620 seeking a place in a cathedral chapter with a purity statute. He submits the names of his parents and four grandparents and their towns. Investigators go to each town and interview old residents under oath: did they ever hear that any of these people descended from Jews or Moors, or had been penanced by the Inquisition? They check the sambenitos in the parish churches. If an old neighbor recalls a rumor about a great grandmother, the application can fail, even though the young man and his whole family have been Christians for a century.

Work out the logic. The test does not ask what the candidate believes or how he lives. It asks what neighbors remember about people long dead, which turns local memory and spite into a legal weapon. It also links the Inquisition's sambenitos directly to social exclusion. This is where the history connects most clearly with the modern idea that people are equal in worth and should be judged by their own acts. A rule that punishes a person for an ancestor's identity, or for gossip about it, denies the very thing that baptism was supposed to guarantee and that equal citizenship guarantees today.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did Archbishop Silíceo do in 1547?
2. What did the Jesuit general congregation of 1593 decide?
3. What did the Tizón de la nobleza argue?
4. Who made up most of those tried for Judaizing in seventeenth century Spain?
5. Which American tribunal opened last, in 1610?
6. Who was excluded from the American tribunals' jurisdiction?
7. What could happen when an enslaved person renounced God under the whip?
8. Who was burned in Mexico City in 1596, leaving letters and a memoir?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia