By the eighteenth century the Inquisition was smaller, slower and less deadly than in its first decades, but it still policed books and ideas. Its end came not from within but from war, revolution and a long struggle between liberals and absolutists. Its memory has been fought over ever since.
The Enlightenment and the tribunal
In the eighteenth century the tribunal pursued freemasons, readers of banned French books and people suspected of unbelief. Its most famous target was Pablo de Olavide, a reforming senior royal official born in Lima who had founded new farming colonies in the Sierra Morena. Olavide was tried and condemned in 1778 for impious ideas, at a private ceremony attended by invited nobles, and sentenced to confinement in a monastery. He later escaped to France. His case shocked enlightened opinion across Europe and showed that even a trusted servant of the crown was not safe.
Abolition, restoration, abolition
When Napoleon's army occupied Spain, Napoleon himself decreed the Inquisition's abolition in December 1808. Spanish patriots fighting the French did the same on their own terms: the Cortes of Cádiz abolished the Inquisition in 1813, declaring it incompatible with the new constitution of 1812. When Ferdinand VII returned in 1814 he restored it. A liberal revolution suppressed it again in 1820. After 1823, when absolutism returned, it was not formally revived, but some bishops set up local boards of faith. In 1826 one of them in Valencia had a schoolteacher, Cayetano Ripoll, garroted for deism, reportedly for replacing prayers in his school with his own words. The Inquisition was finally abolished in 1834, under the regency of María Cristina.
The Black Legend
Spain's enemies had long used the tribunal to paint the country as cruel and fanatical. In 1567 a book published in Heidelberg under the name Reginaldus Gonsalvius Montanus, probably written by Protestant exiles from Seville, described its methods in vivid detail and was quickly translated into English and other languages. In 1817 to 1818 Juan Antonio Llorente, a former secretary of the Inquisition, published a critical history of it in Paris, based on documents he had handled. His estimate of more than thirty thousand people burned is now thought far too high. In 1914 the Spanish writer Julián Juderías coined the term Black Legend for the exaggerated, hostile picture of Spain that such writings had helped create.
Historians argue
Modern research began with the American historian Henry Charles Lea, whose four volume history appeared in 1906 and 1907. In the later twentieth century scholars working in the archives, including Henningsen, Contreras and the British historian Henry Kamen, stressed the lower overall death toll, the bureaucratic routine and the many cases of minor offenses. Much of this work rests on the tribunal's own archive. The records of the Suprema are held today in the National Historical Archive in Madrid, along with files from many local tribunals and from the Americas, though others were lost or destroyed. Historians of ordinary life now mine them for what peasants, servants and merchants said about God, sex, money and their neighbors, since few other sources record such voices at all. Others warned that statistics can numb readers to the fear the tribunal spread and the lives it ruined.
A sharp debate concerns the conversos. Historians such as Yitzhak Baer and Haim Beinart read the trial records as evidence that many conversos really did keep Jewish practices. Benzion Netanyahu argued in 1995 that most conversos were sincere Christians and that the Inquisition was driven by hostility to them as a group, not by real heresy. Each side points to the same problem: the records were produced by a court with the power to imprison and torture, so confessions may reflect what inquisitors wanted to hear, but they also contain details no inquisitor could have invented.
The Catholic Church has also revisited this past. In 1998 the Vatican opened to scholars the archive of the office that succeeded the Roman Inquisition, and in March 2000 Pope John Paul II led a public request for forgiveness for sins committed by Christians, including the use of force and intolerance in the service of truth. Spanish bishops and historians have since joined the discussion of how a church should remember such institutions.
Worked example: what due process remembers
Set the tribunal's procedure beside the rights that later legal systems came to protect. The Inquisition hid accusers' names; modern criminal law in many countries gives the accused the right to confront witnesses. It allowed torture to obtain confessions; international law now bans torture absolutely. It shamed descendants through sambenitos and purity statutes; modern rights declarations hold that guilt is personal. It judged belief; modern constitutions protect freedom of conscience. The Universal Declaration of Human Rights of 1948 says that anyone charged with a crime must be treated as innocent until a public trial establishes guilt.
None of these protections appeared by accident. Many were argued for by people who had seen what secret courts could do, and the Inquisition was one of their great examples. Yet the history also cautions against self congratulation. The tribunal was run by educated, often sincere officials who believed they protected souls and social peace. The safeguards that matter most are those that work even when the people in charge are certain they are right.
