Between the Civil War and 1900, the vast region beyond the Mississippi was drawn into the national economy at tremendous speed. Settlers, miners, ranchers, railroad workers and soldiers poured in. What they built, and what they destroyed, became the subject of one of the most famous arguments in American history.
Land for the taking
The federal government owned most of the West and was eager to give it away. The Homestead Act of 1862 offered 160 acres of public land to settlers who lived on it and farmed it for five years. Eventually about 1.6 million homestead claims were completed, covering roughly a tenth of the country's land. The law fit an old ideal of independent farmers, but it worked unevenly. On the dry plains 160 acres was often too little to make a living, many claims failed, and speculators used false entries to gather land.
Cattle, cowboys and the end of the open range
After the war Texas held millions of half wild longhorn cattle and few buyers. In 1867 a livestock dealer named Joseph McCoy built pens at Abilene, Kansas, beside a new rail line, and cowboys began driving herds north to meet the trains. The cattle trade borrowed heavily from Mexico. Words such as lariat, rodeo and chaps come from the Spanish of the Mexican vaqueros, who had worked cattle on horseback for centuries. The cowboys themselves were far more varied than later films suggested. Many were Mexican or Mexican American, and estimates of the share who were Black range from about one in seven to about one in four.
The open range lasted barely two decades. Joseph Glidden patented a practical barbed wire in 1874, and cheap fencing let landowners close off water and grass. Overgrazing weakened the herds. Barbed wire, along with the brutal winter of 1886 to 1887 that killed huge numbers of cattle, helped end the era of the open range.
Mines, tracks and the people who built them
Mining drew people west as powerfully as land. After the gold rush, California miners turned to hydraulic mining, blasting hillsides with jets of water and washing the debris into rivers. The silt choked channels and buried farms downstream. In 1884 a federal judge, Lorenzo Sawyer, ordered hydraulic miners to stop dumping their debris into California's rivers, a ruling often described as one of the country's first major environmental decisions.
The first transcontinental railroad was built in large part by Chinese workers, who made up most of the Central Pacific's labor force in the Sierra Nevada. They did some of the most dangerous work, boring tunnels through granite in winter. In June 1867 thousands of Chinese workers on the Central Pacific went on strike for pay equal to white workers and shorter shifts in the tunnels. The company cut off their food supplies, and the strike ended within about a week. In the years after the line was finished, anti Chinese violence spread across the West. At Rock Springs, Wyoming, in 1885, white miners killed at least 28 Chinese miners and burned their homes.
The bison
The plains had once held tens of millions of bison, the center of life for many Native nations. In the 1870s a new tanning process made bison hides valuable as industrial leather, and commercial hunters, carried and supplied by the railroads, killed them by the millions. Many army officers welcomed the slaughter because it undermined the nations they were fighting. When the naturalist William Hornaday surveyed the remaining herds in 1889, he estimated that only about a thousand bison were left.
Frontier or conquest?
In 1890 the Census Bureau announced that it could no longer draw a frontier line on its maps. Three years later a young historian, Frederick Jackson Turner, gave a paper in Chicago that shaped how Americans saw their past for half a century. "The existence of an area of free land, its continuous recession, and the advance of American settlement westward, explain American development," he wrote. Turner argued that free land and westward settlement shaped American democracy and character, making the country more individualistic and less bound by European tradition.
Later historians challenged him sharply. Free land, they noted, was only free because it had been taken from people already living on it. Patricia Limerick argued in the 1980s that the West was a place of conquest whose conflicts over land, water and race never really ended, rather than a frontier that closed in 1890. Turner's defenders reply that he identified something real about the role of open land in American life, even if he told only part of the story.
Worked example: one mining town, two stories
Take a silver town like Virginia City, Nevada, at its height in the 1870s. Told Turner's way, it is a story of energy and self government: miners forming their own rules, newcomers rising fast, a raw place becoming a community. Told Limerick's way, it is a story of conquest and lasting conflict: land taken from the Northern Paiute, Chinese residents pushed into a separate quarter, mine owners in San Francisco taking most of the wealth, and rivers and forests stripped to feed the mines. Each telling uses true facts. The useful question is which facts each leaves out, and why.
