Skip to main content

For the Native nations of the West, the Gilded Age was a time of war, confinement and a determined government campaign to erase their ways of life. It was also a time of resistance, of legal argument and of survival.

The Black Hills

After a costly war in the 1860s, the United States signed a treaty at Fort Laramie in 1868 with the Lakota and their allies. The Fort Laramie Treaty of 1868 recognized a Great Sioux Reservation that included the Black Hills, a place sacred to the Lakota, and promised that no white settlers would enter without their consent. In 1874 an army expedition under George Armstrong Custer reported gold in the hills, and miners rushed in.

Many refused. In June 1876, at the Little Bighorn River in Montana, Lakota, Northern Cheyenne and Arapaho warriors led by men including Sitting Bull and Crazy Horse destroyed Custer and about 260 of his soldiers. The victory brought a massive army response, and in 1877 Congress took the Black Hills. The dispute never ended. In 1980 the Supreme Court ruled that the 1877 taking required payment of just compensation with interest. The Lakota nations have refused the award, which has grown to over a billion dollars, because they seek the return of the land itself.

Flight and surrender

In 1877 the government ordered the Nez Perce of Oregon's Wallowa Valley onto a smaller reservation in Idaho. After fighting broke out, several bands, roughly 800 people, fled across Idaho and Montana toward Canada, outmaneuvering army columns for more than a thousand miles. They were caught at the Bear Paw Mountains, about 40 miles short of the border. The surrender speech attributed to Chief Joseph, ending with the promise to "fight no more forever," became one of the most quoted passages in American history. Historians treat the speech with care because it survives through an army officer's version, written down and later polished, not through a Nez Perce record.

Is an Indian a person?

That question was argued in a federal courtroom in Omaha in 1879. The Ponca, a small nation in Nebraska, had been forced south to Indian Territory, where many died. When his son died, a Ponca leader named Standing Bear set out with a small group to bury him in their homeland. The army arrested them. Two lawyers filed for a writ of habeas corpus, which requires the government to justify holding someone. The government's lawyer argued that Standing Bear was not a person in the eyes of the law and could not bring the suit. Judge Elmer Dundy ruled that Standing Bear was a person under the habeas corpus law and could not be held without legal cause. The ruling freed his group, though it did little for Native people generally.

The case drew Helen Hunt Jackson, a poet and writer, into the cause. Her 1881 book A Century of Dishonor detailed broken treaties and massacres. She sent a copy of A Century of Dishonor at her own expense to every member of Congress.

Schools for erasing

Many reformers who condemned violence believed the answer was assimilation: turning Native people into Christian farmers who owned land individually. The Dawes Act of 1887 divided reservations into private plots, and Native landholdings shrank from about 138 million acres to under 50 million by the 1930s. Schooling was the other tool. In 1879 Richard Henry Pratt, an army officer, opened the Carlisle Indian Industrial School in Pennsylvania. The founding aim of the Carlisle school was to strip students of their Native languages, religions and cultures, a goal Pratt summed up in an 1892 speech: "Kill the Indian in him, and save the man." Children's hair was cut, their names changed and their languages forbidden. Hundreds of boarding schools followed. A 2022 federal Interior Department report counted more than 400 such schools and documented deaths of children at many of them.

The Ghost Dance and Wounded Knee

In 1889 a Paiute prophet in Nevada named Wovoka began teaching a new faith. Wovoka's Ghost Dance promised that peaceful dancing and right living would bring a renewed world, with the dead restored and the old abundance returned. On the Lakota reservations, where food rations had just been cut, agents saw it as a threat. Sitting Bull was killed during an attempt to arrest him in December 1890. Two weeks later, on 29 December, soldiers of the Seventh Cavalry disarming a Lakota band at Wounded Knee Creek opened fire, killing about 250 to 300 people, many of them women and children.

Worked example: Standing Bear's argument

Consider the Omaha case as a test of principle. The government's position was technical: Standing Bear was not a citizen, so he had no standing to sue. Standing Bear's lawyers answered that the habeas corpus law protected any "person," and that word could not sensibly exclude a human being. Standing Bear himself spoke at the end, telling the court that his blood was the same color as the judge's and that he felt the same pain. Judge Dundy's ruling rested on the statute, not on a grand theory, but its logic was the core idea of human rights: legal protection begins with recognizing that someone is a person.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did the Fort Laramie Treaty of 1868 recognize?
2. What did the Supreme Court rule in 1980 about the taking of the Black Hills?
3. Why have the Lakota nations refused the Black Hills award?
4. Why do historians treat Chief Joseph's surrender speech with care?
5. What did Judge Elmer Dundy rule in 1879?
6. What did Helen Hunt Jackson do with A Century of Dishonor?
7. How many boarding schools did a 2022 Interior Department report count?
8. What did Wovoka's Ghost Dance promise?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia