
Twenty dollars buys a decent lunch, or several insecticide-treated bed nets for a family living with malaria. Put side by side like that, the lunch starts to look a little strange, and a few young philosophers in Oxford decided to take the strangeness seriously. What grew from their idea has moved billions of dollars, sent graduates into careers picked partly by spreadsheet, and lately staked large sums on protecting people who may not be born for a million years. Then its most celebrated donor went to prison for fraud.
Effective altruism is easy to admire and easy to mock, and both reactions tend to skip the interesting part. Its central argument fits on a postcard and is remarkably hard to escape. Its critics, from Bernard Williams on integrity to Amia Srinivasan on politics, are just as hard to wave away. Work through both, and the old question of how much you owe strangers, and how you would ever know whether your help is helping, becomes something you can reason about in the open rather than settle by guilt, habit or a shrug.
CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia