Skip to main content

Sen liked to compare two people who are both going hungry. One is a wealthy person fasting for religious reasons. The other is poor and cannot afford food. Their bodies may be equally undernourished. Yet their situations differ deeply, because the person who fasts could eat and chooses not to, while the starving person has no choice. The example shows that equal functionings can hide unequal freedoms, and it carries the central distinction of the capabilities approach.

Functionings and capability sets

Functionings are the beings and doings that make up a life: being healthy, being sheltered, working, reading a newspaper, voting, laughing with friends. Some are basic, such as being adequately nourished. Others are complex, such as having self-respect or taking part in the life of a town. A person's actual life at any moment can be described as a combination of functionings.

A capability is a freedom to achieve functionings. More precisely, Sen speaks of a capability set: the combinations of functionings a person could choose from. The fasting person and the starving person have achieved the same functioning, being undernourished, but their capability sets are very different. One set includes being well fed. The other does not.

Why capability and not just functioning

Why should public policy care about the freedom to function and not only about the functioning itself? Defenders give three reasons. First, choice has value of its own: a life chosen is different from the same life imposed, as the fasting case shows. Second, people disagree about how to live. A government that aimed at particular functionings, insisting that everyone exercise or worship or marry, would override that disagreement. Aiming at capabilities leaves people room to decide. Third, focusing on opportunity respects responsibility. An adult who has a real chance to visit a clinic and decides not to is in a different position from one who has no clinic within reach.

Critics reply that capabilities are hard to observe. We can see whether someone is literate. It is far harder to see whether a non-literate adult had a real chance to learn. In practice, researchers often measure functionings and treat them as clues about capabilities, especially where a shortfall is so common or so harmful that it is unlikely to have been chosen.

Conversion factors

Between a resource and a functioning stand what later writers, notably the Belgian philosopher Ingrid Robeyns, call conversion factors. Sen's favorite illustration, from his book Commodities and Capabilities (1985), was a bicycle. A bicycle is a commodity. Being able to move about is the functioning it supports. But how much mobility the bicycle gives depends on the person and the setting. Robeyns sorts these influences into three kinds. Personal conversion factors include physical condition, sex, skills and metabolism: a person who cannot pedal gains little from a bicycle. Social conversion factors include laws and norms: in a society that forbids women to ride, a woman's bicycle is useless to her. Environmental conversion factors include climate, geography and infrastructure: a bicycle is worth more in a flat town with paths than on steep hills with no roads.

Conversion factors explain why equal resources can yield unequal freedoms. They also point to where policy can act. Sometimes the best response is more income. Sometimes it is a ramp, a law, a streetlight or a change in social norms.

Well-being and agency

Sen added a further distinction. A person's well-being concerns how their own life is going. But people also pursue goals that are not about their own well-being: raising a child, defending a cause, protecting a forest. Sen called this agency. Agency freedom is the freedom to pursue goals beyond one's own welfare. A hunger striker gives up well-being in order to exercise agency. Sen insisted that development should treat people as active agents, not passive recipients of aid.

A space, not a full theory

The approach says what to look at when judging how people are doing. It does not by itself say how much equality is required, who owes what to whom, or how to weigh one capability against another. Sen deliberately left these questions open, which is why the approach is often described as a framework or evaluative space rather than a complete theory of justice.

Worked example: one bicycle, two towns

A charity gives identical bicycles to two teenage girls, Lina and Marta, so they can reach secondary school. Lina lives in a flat river town with a paved road, and her parents are pleased to see her ride. Within a month she arrives at school on time every day. Marta lives in a hill village where the only road washes out each rainy season, and older relatives think a girl on a bicycle brings shame on the family. Her bicycle sits in a shed. A resource count says the charity treated the girls equally. A functioning count notes that only Lina now attends school regularly. A capability analysis asks why, and finds an environmental factor (the road) and a social one (the norm). Remedies might include repairing the road or a school bus. The bicycles were not a mistake. But the same good opened very different freedoms, and only by looking at the freedom could the charity tell.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What does Sen's fasting example show?
2. What is a capability set?
3. Which is one reason defenders give for aiming at capability, not functioning?
4. Which of these is a personal conversion factor?
5. Which pair are environmental conversion factors?
6. What is agency freedom?
7. What do conversion factors explain?
8. Why is the approach often called a framework, not a full theory?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia