Skip to main content

If loneliness has social causes, it may have social remedies. Over the past few decades, researchers, governments and ordinary citizens have tried many ways to rebuild connection: through the design of places, through public policy and through new kinds of voluntary groups. Some have strong evidence behind them. Others are promising but untested.

Third places

In The Great Good Place (1989), the sociologist Ray Oldenburg described what he called third places: informal gathering spots beyond home and work, such as cafés, pubs, barbershops and general stores. Home is the first place and work the second. Oldenburg argued that good third places share certain features. They are neutral ground, where nobody is host. They level status, so a lawyer and a plumber meet as equals. Conversation is the main activity, and a core of regulars sets the tone and welcomes newcomers. He worried that car-centered suburbs and chain stores were eliminating such places, leaving people shuttling between home and office.

Social infrastructure

The sociologist Eric Klinenberg studied the Chicago heat wave of July 1995, in which more than 700 people died, most of them old, poor and living alone. He compared neighborhoods with similar poverty and climate but very different death rates. In North Lawndale, streets were emptied by abandonment and crime, and many older residents stayed shut inside. In nearby Little Village, busy shops and sidewalks drew people out, and neighbors checked on one another. Klinenberg concluded that lively streets, shops and public spaces helped older residents survive. In Palaces for the People (2018) he called such places social infrastructure, and singled out public libraries as among the most important, because they are free, open to all and need no reason to visit.

Governments take notice

In June 2016 the British member of Parliament Jo Cox was murdered by a far-right extremist. She had been setting up a commission on loneliness, and colleagues carried it on in her name. Following the Jo Cox Commission's report, Britain appointed a minister for loneliness in January 2018, and later published a national strategy. In 2021, as the pandemic deepened isolation, Japan created a cabinet post for loneliness and isolation, followed by a law setting out national and local duties, which took effect in 2024.

One policy both countries have explored is social prescribing. In England, doctors can refer patients to link workers who connect them with community activities, such as walking groups, gardening projects, choirs or volunteering. The idea is that many visits to doctors are driven partly by loneliness, which medicine alone cannot cure. Evaluations so far are mixed: many participants report feeling better, but strong controlled studies are still few.

Civil society steps in

Many of the liveliest efforts come from citizens. The Men's Sheds movement began in Australia in the 1990s and has spread to Ireland, Britain and beyond. Men's Sheds give men a workshop where they work side by side on shared projects, repairing furniture or building benches for parks. Supporters sum up the idea with a slogan: men do not talk face to face, they talk shoulder to shoulder. Another example began in a London park in 2004, when 13 runners met for a timed five-kilometer run. That became parkrun, which offers free, timed weekly runs open to anyone, including walkers, and now draws millions of people in many countries.

What works best?

In 2011 Christopher Masi, John Cacioppo and colleagues combined studies of loneliness interventions. They grouped them into four kinds: improving social skills, increasing social support, creating more opportunities for contact, and changing unhelpful patterns of social thinking. Surprisingly, interventions that changed how lonely people interpret social situations had the largest effects. Simply putting people in a room together helped less. This fits the lonely mind's tendency to expect rejection: if a person reads every silence as hostility, new opportunities may only produce new disappointments. The finding does not make places and programs useless. It suggests they work best when they also give people a chance to test and revise their fears.

Worked example: a small budget

A town council has a modest budget to reduce loneliness among older residents. It weighs several options against what the evidence shows.

A glossy advertising campaign telling people that loneliness is common would be cheap, but it creates no new contact and changes no habits. The council sets it aside.

Extending library hours into the evening and weekends, adding a coffee corner and running a weekly conversation group draws on Klinenberg's case for social infrastructure and Oldenburg's third places. Benches and shade along the main shopping street encourage people to linger, much as Little Village's busy sidewalks did.

The council also funds a part-time link worker at the medical center, so doctors can refer isolated patients to these activities. Because the strongest evidence favors helping people revise their social expectations, the link worker is trained to follow up after first visits, when many lonely people decide that a group "isn't for them."

Finally, it sets aside a small grant for residents who want to start their own groups, such as a shed or a walking club. The council plans to measure both loneliness and isolation before and after, so that next year's budget can follow results rather than hopes.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did Ray Oldenburg mean by third places?
2. What did Eric Klinenberg conclude from the 1995 Chicago heat wave?
3. What led Britain to appoint a minister for loneliness in 2018?
4. Which country created a cabinet post for loneliness and isolation in 2021?
5. How does social prescribing work in England?
6. What do Men's Sheds offer?
7. Which interventions had the largest effects in the 2011 review by Masi and colleagues?
8. What does parkrun offer?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia