Skip to main content

Friendship is the most freely chosen of human bonds. No law requires it, no ceremony marks it and no one is born into it. Perhaps for that reason it is easily neglected in adult life, squeezed between work and family. Researchers have learned a good deal about how friendships actually form, and much of it is less romantic and more practical than people expect.

An old mystery

Writers have long struggled to explain why a particular friendship takes hold. The French essayist Michel de Montaigne, mourning his friend Étienne de La Boétie, wrote in his essay "Of Friendship," in a line he added after its first printing in 1580, that if pressed to say why he loved him, he could answer only "because it was he, because it was I," as the line is usually translated. Montaigne meant that the deepest friendships cannot be reduced to reasons. Modern research does not refute him, but it shows that the conditions which allow such a bond to begin are surprisingly ordinary.

Proximity

Around 1950 the psychologists Leon Festinger, Stanley Schachter and Kurt Back studied Westgate, a housing complex for married students at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. Residents were assigned apartments more or less at random, which made a natural experiment. When asked to name their friends, residents were far more likely to name next-door neighbors than people living a few doors away. Physical layout mattered too: people whose doors faced the stairways or mailboxes, where others passed, made more friends than those tucked at the ends.

Sociologists have since described three conditions that help friendships form: physical closeness, repeated contact that is not planned in advance, and a setting that encourages people to relax and open up. Schools, dormitories, military service and early jobs supply all three. In adulthood the settings that supply these conditions tend to fade, as people move for work, start families and spend evenings at home, which helps explain why making friends feels harder after the twenties.

Friendship takes time

How long does it take? In 2018 the communication scholar Jeffrey Hall surveyed adults who had recently moved and students starting university. He estimated that it takes about 50 hours together to go from acquaintance to casual friend, about 90 hours to become a real friend, and more than 200 hours to become a close friend. The kind of time mattered as well. Hours spent joking, catching up and doing things together counted for more than hours spent working side by side on assigned tasks.

How many friends can a person have?

In the early 1990s the anthropologist Robin Dunbar noticed that across primate species, the size of the neocortex, the brain's outer layer, tracked the size of the social group. Extending the pattern to humans, Dunbar based his famous number on brain size and group size in primates, predicting that people can maintain about 150 meaningful relationships. He later proposed that these come in layers, roughly 5, 15, 50 and 150 people, each about three times the size of the one inside it, with time and emotional closeness shrinking as the circles widen.

The idea is popular with companies and planners, but it has critics. In 2021 a team of researchers re-ran the analysis with modern statistical methods and newer primate data, and found that the estimates varied far too widely to support any single number, ranging from a handful to several hundred. Dunbar responded that his number was never meant to be precise. Most researchers accept a weaker version of the idea: close relationships take time, time is limited, and so the inner circle is always small.

Screens and friendship

Phones and the internet complicate the picture. Online contact helps people keep up with distant friends and family, and lets those with rare interests or identities find others like them. Studies tend to find that using technology to arrange and extend face-to-face contact goes along with stronger friendships, while time online that replaces meeting in person goes along with weaker ones. The research is still contested, and effects seem to differ greatly from person to person.

Worked example: Marcus starts over

Marcus, 34, moves to a new city where he knows no one. His first instinct is to wait for friendships to happen, as they did at university. Applying what researchers have found, he tries something different.

He joins a climbing gym that runs a group session every Tuesday evening. The same dozen people come each week, so he gets repeated, unplanned conversation with familiar faces in a relaxed setting: all three conditions at once. At about three hours a week, including the drink some of them have afterward, he reaches 50 hours with the regulars in about four months. Hall's figures suggest he should expect casual friends by then, not best friends, which keeps him from giving up too soon.

He also chooses an apartment near the building's entrance rather than at the end of a quiet corridor, remembering Westgate. A year on, Marcus has two people he would call friends and a wider circle of friendly acquaintances. It took steady time, which is what most of the evidence predicts.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. How did Montaigne explain his friendship with La Boétie?
2. What did the Westgate housing study find?
3. Which is one of the three conditions that help friendships form?
4. According to Jeffrey Hall, how much time together does a close friendship take?
5. On what did Robin Dunbar base his number of about 150 relationships?
6. Which sizes did Dunbar propose for the layers of a person's social circles?
7. What did a 2021 reanalysis of Dunbar's number find?
8. Why might friendships be harder to make after the twenties, according to the level?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia