Skip to main content

Belonging is usually treated as a simple good. It is not always. The same hunger for connection that leads people to choirs and clubs can lead them to gangs and extremist movements, and groups that bind their members tightly can shut others out. This final level looks at belonging as a public matter, with consequences for freedom, trust and democratic life.

When belonging turns dangerous

Researchers who study radicalization often note that ideology is rarely the first attraction. Recruiters to violent movements frequently target young people who are isolated, humiliated or adrift, and offer them brotherhood, purpose and a sense that they matter. The psychologist Arie Kruglanski describes this as a quest for significance, the need to feel that one counts, which extremist groups exploit by promising heroism to people who feel invisible. The same need can be met in healthy ways, through work, family, faith, sport or service, which is one reason communities with strong ordinary ties may resist extremism better.

Arendt on loneliness

The political theorist Hannah Arendt, who fled Nazi Germany, made loneliness central to her account of totalitarianism. In the closing chapter of The Origins of Totalitarianism, added to the 1958 edition, she argued that totalitarian movements drew their strength from masses of lonely, uprooted people, cut off from the ordinary relationships through which people test their ideas against reality. Someone with no one to talk to is more easily captured by an ideology that explains everything.

Arendt carefully distinguished loneliness from solitude. In her account, a person in solitude keeps company with oneself and can think, while the lonely person feels abandoned even by that inner companion. Her point echoes the distinction between chosen solitude and painful loneliness, and gives it political weight: free people need both time alone to think and a shared world in which to act.

Diversity and trust

In 2007 Robert Putnam published an uncomfortable finding from a survey of about 30,000 Americans in 41 communities. In the short run, residents of more diverse communities tended to "hunker down," trusting neighbors less, even those of their own group, and withdrawing from community life. Putnam, who supports immigration, presented the finding as a challenge rather than a verdict. He argued that over time, societies have built new and broader shared identities, pointing to examples such as the integration of the US military and religious congregations that welcomed members of many backgrounds.

Later researchers questioned how general the effect is. In a 2015 study, the sociologists Maria Abascal and Delia Baldassarri argued that much of the apparent effect came from economic disadvantage and from white residents' responses, rather than from diversity itself lowering trust among everyone. Reviews of studies in many countries find that diversity is often linked to slightly lower trust among neighbors, but has little consistent effect on trust in general. Findings like this are easily stretched, in either direction, beyond what they show.

Small acts, underestimated

Some of the most practical research concerns everyday encounters. In a series of studies published in 2014, the psychologists Nicholas Epley and Juliana Schroeder asked commuters on Chicago trains and buses to talk to a stranger, keep to themselves or behave as usual. Most people predicted that talking would be unpleasant. In fact, commuters enjoyed talking to strangers much more than they had predicted, and the strangers seemed to welcome it too. The same year, Gillian Sandstrom and Elizabeth Dunn found that coffee buyers who chatted briefly with the barista felt more connected afterward than those who kept the exchange efficient.

A related finding is called the liking gap. In studies led by Erica Boothby in 2018, pairs of strangers had a conversation and then rated each other. People consistently underestimated how much their new partner liked them.

Belonging and dignity

These findings connect to a basic principle of human dignity. Being recognized by others is not a luxury but part of what it means to be treated as a person. This is why prolonged solitary confinement is widely condemned. The United Nations' revised standards for the treatment of prisoners, known as the Mandela Rules (2015), restrict solitary confinement for more than 15 consecutive days. A democracy also needs citizens who know one another well enough to disagree and cooperate.

Worked example: two invitations

Kyle, 20, lost his job when a warehouse closed and moved back to his mother's house in a town where most friends have left. He spends nights in an online forum where angry young men blame outsiders for their troubles, and where someone notices when he logs on. Without saying so, it answers his quest for significance.

A neighbor who coaches at a boxing gym asks if he would like to help with the youth class on Saturdays. Kyle nearly says no, sure the kids will find him awkward, the liking gap at work. He goes anyway. Within weeks the regulars greet him by name, and a nine-year-old asks when he will be back.

Both places offer belonging. The difference lies in what each asks of him. The forum demands an enemy, while the gym asks for patience, reliability and care for people unlike himself, in a shared world where his ideas meet other people's. Arendt's warning and the research on small encounters point to the same lesson: belonging is built in ordinary places, one invitation at a time, and a community that offers none leaves its lonely members to whoever does.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did Hannah Arendt argue about totalitarian movements?
2. How did Arendt distinguish solitude from loneliness?
3. What did Putnam's 2007 study find in more diverse communities in the short run?
4. What did Putnam argue would happen over time?
5. What did Abascal and Baldassarri argue in 2015?
6. What did Epley and Schroeder find about commuters who talked to strangers?
7. What is the liking gap?
8. What does Kruglanski mean by the quest for significance?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia