If some people know far more than others about economics, medicine and engineering, why should every adult have an equal say in decisions about them? The question is as old as democracy, and it returns whenever voters reject expert advice or experts make decisions voters never chose. How a free people should use expertise without being ruled by it is one of the central puzzles of self-government.
The case for rule by those who know
Plato argued in the Republic that a ship should be steered by a trained navigator, not by whichever sailors shout loudest, and that a city likewise should be ruled by those with knowledge of the good. Plato's core argument was that governing is a skill, and skills belong to those who have mastered them.
John Stuart Mill, a firm defender of representative government, still worried about uninformed majorities. In Considerations on Representative Government (1861) Mill proposed giving extra votes to people with more education or more demanding occupations, while insisting that everyone should have at least one vote. Some philosophers today revive versions of the idea under the name epistocracy, rule by the knowledgeable, proposing tests for voters or extra weight for informed ones.
Critics reply with several objections. The philosopher David Estlund raised what he called the demographic objection: those who would pass a knowledge test differ from others by class, race and region, so their judgments may carry hidden biases that would then be built into law. Others argue that political equality expresses the equal worth of persons, and that no exam can measure who deserves a voice in decisions that bind everyone.
Lippmann and Dewey
In 1922 the American journalist Walter Lippmann published Public Opinion, observing that "the world that we have to deal with politically is out of reach, out of sight, out of mind." Lippmann argued that ordinary citizens cannot master the facts of modern government, and that expert bodies should prepare the knowledge decision makers need.
The philosopher John Dewey answered in The Public and Its Problems (1927). Experts may know remedies, he agreed, but they do not automatically know where the problems are. In his words, "The man who wears the shoe knows best that it pinches and where it pinches, even if the expert shoemaker is the best judge of how the trouble is to be remedied." For Dewey, those affected by a policy know where it hurts, while experts may know best how to fix it. He warned that experts cut off from the public would come to serve their own interests.
The guest and the cook
Aristotle made a related point long before. Discussing whether the many should judge, he wrote in the Politics that in some arts the user is the better judge, and "the guest will judge better of a feast than the cook." Aristotle's point was that the people who live with a thing can sometimes judge its results better than the experts who made it. A city's residents can tell whether a new transport system serves them, even if they could not have designed it.
Technocrats in office
Some democracies have handed government directly to experts in emergencies. In November 2011, with Italy's borrowing costs soaring, the economist Mario Monti became prime minister at the head of a cabinet with no elected politicians. It passed a pension reform and spending cuts that parties had long avoided. In the 2013 election Monti's coalition won only about a tenth of the vote. Technocratic governments can act when parties are deadlocked, but they lack a democratic mandate, and voters may punish them later.
Facts and values
Much of the tension eases once facts and values are separated, at least roughly. Experts can say what is likely to happen under each option. Which risks are acceptable and who should bear them are questions for citizens. The science policy scholar Roger Pielke Jr. described several roles an expert can take, and argued that one is too rare: the honest broker, who lays out the range of options and their likely consequences rather than pushing one. Some countries have built forums for this. Since 1987 Denmark has held consensus conferences in which a panel of ordinary citizens questions experts in public and writes recommendations for parliament.
Worked example: the Eastern Scheldt barrier
In February 1953 a storm surge broke through the dikes of the southwestern Netherlands and killed more than 1,800 people. The government responded with the Delta Plan, a series of dams to shorten the coastline. Engineers planned to close the Eastern Scheldt estuary completely with a solid dam.
By the 1970s fishermen, oyster and mussel growers and environmental groups objected that a closed estuary would destroy one of Europe's richest tidal ecosystems and a way of life. The engineers' safety case was sound, but the residents were pointing to costs the plan had not weighed. Parliament asked the experts for alternatives, and in 1976 chose a storm surge barrier with 62 movable gates, left open in normal weather so the tides could flow and closed only in storms. It cost far more and was finished in 1986. The engineers supplied the options and their consequences. The public and its representatives chose among values. The country ended up with both safety and a living estuary, a result neither side would have reached alone.
