Skip to main content

Before lunch today you probably relied on dozens of people you will never meet. You trusted that a bridge would hold, that a medicine's dose was safe and that the Earth goes around the Sun. You have checked almost none of this for yourself, and you could not check most of it if you tried. Living in a modern society means living on borrowed knowledge.

A web of borrowed knowledge

In a 1985 essay called "Epistemic Dependence," the American philosopher John Hardwig made a claim that sounds odd at first. A layperson who believes something on the word of an expert is often more rational than one who insists on judging alone, because the layperson lacks the training to weigh the evidence and is more likely to get it wrong.

Hardwig added that experts depend on one another just as much. A modern experiment may need physicists, engineers, statisticians and programmers, and no single member can check every step. The 2015 paper that combined the ATLAS and CMS measurements of the Higgs boson's mass listed more than 5,000 authors. Each of them trusted the others' parts of the work.

Words that lean on experts

Dependence runs even into language. In 1975 the philosopher Hilary Putnam admitted that he could not tell an elm from a beech. Yet when he said "elm," he still meant elms and not beeches. How? Because somewhere there are botanists and foresters who can tell the difference, and the word's meaning is anchored by their skill. Putnam called this the division of linguistic labor: ordinary speakers rely on experts to fix what some of their words pick out.

Locke's ideal

Not every thinker welcomed this dependence. John Locke, in his Essay Concerning Human Understanding of 1690, wrote that "we may as rationally hope to see with other men's eyes, as to know by other men's understanding." He went on: "The floating of other men's opinions in our brains makes us not one jot the more knowing, though they happen to be true." Locke held that real knowledge must be grasped by one's own understanding, and that opinions taken on trust do not count as knowledge.

Locke's ideal remains a useful warning against swallowing whatever one is told, especially by the powerful. As a rule for daily life, though, it cannot be followed. No one could rebuild chemistry, history and medicine from scratch before deciding what to eat or whether to take an antibiotic.

Hume and Reid on testimony

Two Scottish philosophers of the eighteenth century gave rival accounts of why trusting what others say can be reasonable. David Hume, in his 1748 essay "Of Miracles," argued that our confidence in testimony is "derived from no other principle than our observation of the veracity of human testimony, and of the usual conformity of facts to the reports of witnesses." For Hume, trust in testimony is justified by past experience that reports usually match the facts.

Thomas Reid, writing in 1764, thought this got human life backwards. A small child believes what it is told long before it could have checked enough reports to justify doing so. Reid described two matching principles built into human nature: "a propensity to speak truth" and "a disposition to confide in the veracity of others." For Reid, people are made to trust testimony by default, and experience then trims that trust where it proves misplaced.

Each view has a weakness. Hume's seems to demand more checking than anyone has done, while Reid's default trust is exactly what liars exploit. Most philosophers today land in between: trust in testimony is a reasonable starting point, but it must stay open to revision when evidence of unreliability appears.

The real question

If total self-reliance is impossible, the question is never whether to trust but whom, about what and how far. Trust has three parts: someone trusts someone about something. You may trust your dentist completely about teeth and not at all about investments, and both attitudes can be sensible at once. Trust is not a single dial set to high or low for "experts" as a class. Forgetting this, people treat one expert's failure in one field as a reason to distrust all experts everywhere.

Worked example: the headache tablet

You have a headache and take a tablet from a box in the cupboard. Consider how much you are relying on. Chemists designed the compound decades ago. Researchers you will never meet ran trials to find a safe dose. A regulator reviewed those trials and approved the wording on the box. A factory made the tablet to a standard, and inspectors checked the factory. You verified none of these steps.

Is your trust reasonable? Mostly, yes, and not because each person in the chain is a saint. The chain has checks built in: rival companies watch for each other's failures, doctors report bad reactions, regulators can withdraw a product and courts can punish negligence. Your trust is in a system with ways of catching errors, not in a single person's word.

Your own judgment still has a job. You read the label, you notice if the pills look different from usual, and you ask a pharmacist whether this medicine is safe with another one you take. Depending on others does not mean switching off. It means directing your attention to the points where your own knowledge actually counts.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did John Hardwig argue in his 1985 essay on epistemic dependence?
2. About how many authors did the 2015 combined paper on the Higgs boson's mass list?
3. What did Hilary Putnam mean by the division of linguistic labor?
4. What did Locke hold about opinions taken on trust?
5. According to Hume, what justifies trusting testimony?
6. Which two principles did Thomas Reid say are built into human nature?
7. Where do most philosophers today land between Hume and Reid?
8. According to the level, what three parts does trust have?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia