Skip to main content

In the 1870s a slogan spread through Tokyo's newspapers and print shops: bunmei kaika, "civilization and enlightenment." It meant learning from the West in nearly everything, from law and schooling to hairstyles and diet. Some of this was eager curiosity, some was strategy, since Western powers said they would treat Japan as an equal only when it had "civilized" laws. Much of it was both.

The Iwakura Mission

In December 1871 about a hundred people sailed from Yokohama for a tour of the United States and Europe that lasted until September 1873. Nearly half the leading figures of the government went, including Iwakura Tomomi, Okubo Toshimichi, Kido Takayoshi and Ito Hirobumi, along with dozens of students. Five girls were sent to study in America, and the youngest member was Tsuda Umeko, aged six, who in 1900 founded a school for women's higher education in Tokyo. The mission's diplomatic goal was a start on revising the unequal treaties, but the Western governments would not budge, and the mission failed to win any revision of the treaties. Its real harvest was knowledge of factories, schools, parliaments and armies, seen at first hand.

Teachers, tracks and wires

The government hired thousands of foreign experts over the Meiji era, some paid more than cabinet ministers, while sending Japanese students abroad to replace them as soon as possible. A telegraph line linked Tokyo and Yokohama in 1869 and a national postal service began in 1871. In October 1872 the first railway opened between Shimbashi in Tokyo and Yokohama, a run of about 29 kilometers built with British engineers and British loans. The same month a state model silk mill opened at Tomioka, built and run with French experts and machinery, to show private owners how to reel silk to Western standards. Its first workers were often daughters of former samurai families, recruited partly to quiet rumors that the foreigners drank blood, which turned out to be red wine.

A new calendar and new schools

Time itself was reformed. The government announced late in 1872 that Japan would adopt the Gregorian calendar, so that the third day of the twelfth month of the old lunar calendar became 1 January 1873. Officials noted privately that skipping most of December, and avoiding an extra leap month due in 1873, saved two months of salaries. The Education System Order of 1872 drew on French models of centralized school districts and aimed at schooling for every child, girls included. Families resented the fees and the loss of children's labor, and attendance began low, but it climbed past 90 percent of children by the early 1900s, after fees for primary school ended in 1900.

New ideas

Translators poured Western thought into Japanese. In 1871 Nakamura Masanao translated Samuel Smiles's Self-Help, a collection of stories about men who rose through effort, and it became one of the best sellers of the age. He followed it in 1872 with John Stuart Mill's On Liberty. In 1873 a group of scholars and officials founded the Meiji Six Society to discuss reform, and its journal debated everything from writing systems to the place of religion. In a series of essays, Mori Arinori argued that marriage should rest on equal rights and duties between husband and wife, and he attacked the keeping of concubines. The journal closed in 1875 after the government tightened its press laws, a sign that enlightenment had limits.

Gods and temples

Religion was reshaped too. In 1868 the government ordered Shinto shrines and Buddhist temples, long intertwined, to be separated, and it promoted Shinto as a support for the throne. The separation set off attacks on Buddhist temples, with statues smashed, scriptures burned and, in some domains such as Satsuma, almost every temple closed. The violence faded by the mid 1870s, and Buddhism recovered, but the episode showed how quickly a state policy on belief could become a license for destruction.

Worked example: what to copy

The historian Kume Kunitake kept the official record of the Iwakura Mission, published in five volumes in 1878. Its pages show the travelers weighing what Japan should take and what it should leave. They admired American schools and British factories, worried about the poverty of London's slums, and were struck that Prussia, a recently unified state ringed by rivals, had grown strong so fast. Kume observed that much of Europe's wealth was only a few decades old, which suggested to the travelers that the gap with Japan could be closed.

That judgment shaped what came next. The returning leaders chose to put reform at home before adventures abroad, and to borrow selectively: British models for the navy and railways, French and later German models for law and the army, American ideas for some schooling and farming in Hokkaido. Critics then and now point out that selective borrowing could leave out the parts of Western practice that limited power, such as a free press and accountable government. The lesson is double. Learning from others is a mark of confidence, not weakness. But what a country chooses not to copy reveals its priorities as clearly as what it does.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Who was the youngest member of the Iwakura Mission?
2. What did the Iwakura Mission fail to achieve?
3. Which places did Japan's first railway link in 1872?
4. Where did French experts help open a model silk mill in 1872?
5. Which change to timekeeping took effect on 1 January 1873?
6. Which Western book did Nakamura Masanao translate in 1871?
7. What did Mori Arinori argue about marriage?
8. What followed the order separating Shinto and Buddhism in 1868?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia