Who should share in power? The leaders of the 1870s, a small circle mostly from Satsuma and Choshu, saw themselves as the emperor's trustees. Critics called them a clique. Between 1874 and 1890 that argument produced Japan's first political parties, a remarkable wave of popular constitution writing and, finally, a constitution handed down from above.
The rights movement
In January 1874 Itagaki Taisuke and other leaders who had resigned over the Korea dispute petitioned for an elected assembly, arguing that a government that taxed the people must hear them. The Freedom and People's Rights Movement grew from this start. Political societies formed first in Itagaki's home of Tosa, then across the country. Village headmen, rich farmers, teachers and former samurai held lecture meetings, read translations of Rousseau and Mill, and drafted petitions. Newspapers multiplied, and editors who criticized officials were often fined or jailed under the press laws of 1875. Women spoke too. Kishida Toshiko gave public speeches on women's rights, and in 1883 she was arrested after a speech in Otsu comparing sheltered daughters to goods kept in boxes.
Constitutions from below
Dozens of private groups wrote draft constitutions. The rights activist Ueki Emori produced one in 1881 that protected free speech and assembly and included a right to resist a tyrannical government. In 1968 a team of historians found a forgotten draft in an old storehouse in the village of Itsukaichi, west of Tokyo. Written around 1881, mainly by a young schoolteacher named Chiba Takusaburo after study and debate with local farmers, it had 204 articles, about 150 of them on the rights of the people. Its discovery changed how historians see the movement: constitutional thinking had reached deep into the countryside.
The crisis of 1881
Pressure peaked in 1881. A plan to sell off state assets of the Hokkaido Colonization Office cheaply to businessmen tied to its Satsuma chief caused a public scandal. The leaders cancelled the sale, forced out Okuma Shigenobu, a colleague who had urged a British-style parliament soon, and had the emperor promise a national assembly by 1890. The movement turned into parties: Itagaki's Liberal Party in 1881 and Okuma's Constitutional Reform Party in 1882.
Deflation and revolt
At the same time the finance minister Matsukata Masayoshi cut spending and withdrew paper money to stop inflation. Rice and silk prices collapsed, and indebted farmers lost their land. In the silk district of Chichibu, northwest of Tokyo, thousands of farmers rose in November 1884, burning debt records and calling for delayed repayments. The army crushed the Chichibu revolt within days. Radicals in other places plotted risings, and the Liberal Party dissolved itself in 1884. Late in 1887 the government expelled hundreds of activists from Tokyo under new security regulations.
A constitution given by the emperor
Ito Hirobumi led the drafting in secret, after study in Europe, and created a cabinet in 1885, with himself as first prime minister, and a Privy Council to review the text. The constitution was promulgated on 11 February 1889 as a gift from the emperor to his subjects. The emperor was declared sacred and inviolable, and the emperor held supreme command of the army and navy, a clause that later let military leaders claim independence from the cabinet. The same day the education minister Mori Arinori, the former champion of equal marriage, was stabbed by a nationalist who thought him disrespectful to the imperial shrines, and he died the next morning. Ito's own commentary, published that year, explained each article as an expression of the imperial will, and it became the standard guide for officials. The Diet that first met in 1890 had real power over new laws and taxes, but if it rejected a budget, the previous year's budget would remain in force. In 1890 a new law also barred women from attending political meetings. That October the Imperial Rescript on Education called on subjects to honor their parents, study and offer themselves bravely to the state, and copies were placed in every school.
Worked example: a teacher who did not bow
In January 1891, at a ceremony at the First Higher Middle School in Tokyo, teachers and students were asked to bow before the emperor's signature on the Rescript. Uchimura Kanzo, a Christian teacher, stepped up and gave only a slight nod rather than the deep bow expected. He later explained that he had hesitated because he feared that worshipping a document would betray his faith. Students and newspapers attacked him as disloyal, he fell ill, and he was pushed to resign.
Uchimura did not reject the emperor; he later said he would bow if the bow meant respect, not worship. The furor shows how the line between civic respect and religious worship had become a matter of state. The government described state Shinto as civic custom rather than religion, which let it require rituals while claiming to respect freedom of belief. The case asks a lasting question. When a state demands gestures of loyalty, who decides what those gestures mean: the state that requires them, or the conscience of the person asked to make them?
