Skip to main content

Adulthood is the longest stretch of most lives and, oddly, one of the least studied. Childhood has its milestones and old age its worries, but the decades between twenty-five and sixty-five were long treated as a stable plateau. They are not. People form and lose partnerships, raise children or decide not to, change jobs, care for parents, and slowly change in personality and outlook. Researchers have tried to find order in this long middle, with mixed success.

Love and the next generation

Erikson placed two tensions in adulthood. In early adulthood the task is intimacy versus isolation: forming close, committed relationships without losing oneself. In middle adulthood it is generativity versus stagnation. Generativity is concern for guiding and nurturing the next generation, through raising children but also through teaching, mentoring, building institutions or making things that will outlast oneself. Its opposite is a self-absorbed sense that life has stalled. In the 1990s the psychologist Dan McAdams and colleagues developed questionnaires to measure generativity and found it linked with life satisfaction and with civic involvement, such as voting, volunteering and taking part in community groups.

The social clock

The American psychologist Bernice Neugarten, working in Chicago from the 1950s on, found that people carry a social clock: shared expectations about the ages at which major life events should happen, such as leaving home, marrying, having children or retiring. People described themselves as early, late or on time. She found that off-time events, such as being widowed young, tend to be harder than the same event at the expected age, partly because there are fewer peers who share the experience and fewer social scripts for handling it. In many societies the clock has grown looser since Neugarten's day, but it has not vanished, as anyone asked at a family gathering when they plan to settle down can confirm.

Is there a midlife crisis?

The Canadian psychoanalyst Elliott Jaques coined the phrase midlife crisis in a 1965 essay, drawing on the lives of artists who changed course or stopped creating in their late thirties. In The Seasons of a Man's Life (1978), Daniel Levinson and colleagues interviewed 40 American men and described a turbulent midlife transition between about 40 and 45. Both accounts rested on small, selected groups.

Larger surveys tell a calmer story. The Midlife in the United States study (MIDUS), begun in 1995 with several thousand adults, asked people directly. About a quarter said they had had a midlife crisis, but when researchers applied a stricter definition, an upheaval driven by awareness of aging rather than by an outside event, only about one in ten qualified. Many "crises" were really responses to divorce, illness or job loss that could have struck at any age. Midlife brings real pressures, but a crisis is not a normal or inevitable stage.

The dip in the middle

A related claim concerns happiness. In 2008 the economists David Blanchflower and Andrew Oswald analyzed surveys of about half a million people, along with data from dozens of countries, and reported a U-shape: average life satisfaction falls from early adulthood to a low point in the mid to late forties, then rises again. The pattern appeared after taking account of income, marriage and other factors. Critics object that the curve depends heavily on which factors are controlled for, and that some studies following the same people over time find a flatter line. The dip, where it exists, is also small compared with the differences between individuals.

Personality and the sandwich years

Personality keeps changing as well. On average, adults become more organized, more agreeable and calmer between their twenties and their sixties, a pattern some researchers call the maturity principle. Midlife adults also often carry heavy loads of care. In 1981 the social worker Dorothy Miller described the sandwich generation: adults caught between caring for their children and for their aging parents at the same time, often while holding down a job. The load falls disproportionately on women, and it is one reason why paid family leave and support for unpaid carers matter for health in the middle of life.

Worked example: Daniel at 47

Daniel, 47, tells a friend he is having a midlife crisis. His job feels stale, his teenage daughter barely speaks to him, and his father has just had a stroke. A lifespan view would unpack this. The MIDUS findings suggest that what he feels is probably not a stage he was bound to reach, but a pile-up of events: a parent's illness, a teenager pulling away, a plateau at work. He is squarely in the sandwich generation. The U-shape research suggests that if he is at a low point, it is likely to lift. Erikson's idea of generativity offers a direction rather than a diagnosis: Daniel might find renewed purpose in mentoring a younger colleague, coaching his daughter's team or organizing his father's care with his siblings. Neugarten's social clock may explain some of his unease too, since he had expected to be further along by now. Seeing which of these forces are at work helps him decide what to change and what to wait out.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What is generativity, in Erikson's sense?
2. Which tension did Erikson place in early adulthood?
3. What is Neugarten's social clock?
4. What did Neugarten find about off-time events?
5. In MIDUS, roughly what share qualified as having a midlife crisis under a strict definition?
6. What does the evidence suggest about the midlife crisis?
7. What does the U-shape in life satisfaction describe?
8. What is the sandwich generation?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia