Skip to main content

Ask a five-year-old who is naughtier: a boy who accidentally broke fifteen cups while coming in to dinner, or a boy who broke one cup while sneaking jam from a high shelf. Many young children pick the first boy, because he broke more. Ask a ten-year-old and the answer usually flips. How children move from counting damage to weighing intentions is one of the central questions in the study of moral development.

Piaget: from rules to agreements

The cups story comes from Jean Piaget's The Moral Judgment of the Child (1932). Piaget also played marbles with Swiss children and asked them where the rules came from. Younger children, he found, showed what he called heteronomous morality: they judged acts by their consequences and treated rules as fixed by authority, as unchangeable as the laws of nature. Older children moved toward autonomous morality, in which intentions matter and rules are agreements that the players can change together. Piaget believed that cooperation among equals, more than obedience to adults, drove this change.

Kohlberg's stages

The American psychologist Lawrence Kohlberg extended Piaget's work in his 1958 doctoral study of 72 boys in the Chicago area, many of whom he followed for decades. He posed dilemmas, the most famous about a man named Heinz whose wife is dying. A druggist has a medicine that might save her but charges far more than Heinz can pay. Should Heinz steal it? Kohlberg scored the reasoning behind an answer, not the answer itself, since "yes" and "no" can each be defended at every level. He described three levels, each with two stages:

  • Preconventional: right and wrong are defined by punishment, reward and self-interest.
  • Conventional: right means meeting the expectations of family and society and upholding its laws.
  • Postconventional: right is judged by principles, such as rights and justice, that can stand above a society's actual rules.

Kohlberg's research showed slow movement through the stages across adolescence and early adulthood. It also showed that the highest stage was so rare that he eventually stopped scoring it. Critics raised two main problems. First, reviews of cross-cultural studies found postconventional reasoning rare in many traditional village societies, which raised the worry that the scheme treated one Western, liberal outlook as the summit of moral growth. Second, reasoning well about a dilemma does not guarantee acting well in life.

Gilligan and the ethic of care

Kohlberg's original sample was all male. Carol Gilligan, who had worked with him, argued in In a Different Voice (1982) that his stages heard one moral language, built on rights, rules and fairness, and missed another. She described an ethic of care, a moral outlook centered on relationships, responsibility and the needs of particular people, which she heard often in women's reasoning and which Kohlberg's scoring tended to rank lower. Later research tempered the gender claim. A 2000 meta-analysis by Sara Jaffee and Janet Shibley Hyde found only small differences between women and men, with both sexes using both kinds of reasoning, depending largely on the dilemma. Gilligan's lasting contribution was to set care beside justice as a serious moral perspective.

Morality versus convention

Elliot Turiel and his colleagues showed that children sort rules early. Preschoolers say that talking without raising a hand would be fine if the teacher allowed it, but that hitting another child would still be wrong even if the teacher allowed that too. Young children separate moral rules about harm and fairness from social conventions that depend on authority or custom.

Some researchers look earlier still. In 2007 Kiley Hamlin, Karen Wynn and Paul Bloom showed six- and ten-month-olds a puppet trying to climb a hill, helped by one character and pushed down by another, and reported that most babies then reached for the helper. A large multi-laboratory attempt to repeat the study, published in 2025, did not find a clear preference, so how early such judgments appear remains uncertain.

How parents help

Discipline style matters too. The psychologist Martin Hoffman distinguished power assertion, such as threats and punishment, from induction, which means explaining to a child how their actions affect other people. Studies he reviewed linked induction with a stronger conscience and more concern for others, since it points the child's attention toward the person harmed rather than toward the parent's anger.

Worked example: the borrowed bike

Twelve-year-old Leila takes her neighbor's bike without asking to fetch medicine for her sick grandmother, and brings it back scratched. Asked whether she did wrong, a much younger child might focus on the scratch: damage was done, so she was bad. Answers at Kohlberg's preconventional level might ask whether she will be punished. Conventional answers might say that taking things without asking breaks the rules good neighbors keep. Postconventional answers might weigh her grandmother's welfare against the neighbor's property and ask what rule everyone could accept. Gilligan would hear a different question: what does Leila owe to both people in this web of relationships, and how should she repair things with the neighbor? A parent using induction would not simply punish her. They would ask her to imagine how the neighbor felt on finding the bike gone, and help her decide how to make amends.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. In Piaget's account, how do younger children judge acts?
2. What did Kohlberg score when people answered the Heinz dilemma?
3. At Kohlberg's conventional level, what defines right?
4. What did reviews of cross-cultural studies of Kohlberg's stages find?
5. What is Gilligan's ethic of care?
6. What did Jaffee and Hyde's 2000 meta-analysis find?
7. What did Turiel's research show about young children?
8. What is induction, in Hoffman's sense?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia