Skip to main content

A liberal pope?

In June 1846 the cardinals elected Pius IX, who quickly granted an amnesty to political prisoners, eased censorship and allowed a civic guard in Rome. Crowds cheered him, and Gioberti's dream of a pope leading Italy suddenly looked possible. Other rulers felt pressure to follow his reforms. The enthusiasm rested on a misunderstanding. Pius was a kindly reformer of administration, not a nationalist, and he would not trade his spiritual role for a political one.

Palermo goes first

The year of revolutions in Europe began not in Paris but in Sicily. On 12 January 1848 Palermo rose against rule from Naples. King Ferdinand II, alarmed, granted a constitution. The rulers of Tuscany, the Papal States and Piedmont followed within weeks. On 4 March 1848 King Charles Albert of Piedmont issued the Statuto Albertino, a constitution that set up an elected chamber, an appointed senate and civil rights for citizens while keeping strong royal power. Nobody guessed then that this cautious document would outlast every other.

Milan and Venice

When news arrived that Metternich had fallen in Vienna, Milan exploded. In the Five Days of 18 to 22 March 1848, citizens built barricades and drove the Austrian garrison out of the city. Field Marshal Radetzky withdrew his army to the four fortress towns of the Quadrilateral, around Verona and Mantua. In Venice a lawyer named Daniele Manin led a rising that proclaimed the Republic of San Marco.

Charles Albert declared war on Austria on 23 March. His slogan was "Italy will do it by herself", meaning that Italians would win their freedom without foreign help. Volunteers came from across the peninsula, and Tuscany, Rome and Naples sent troops. For a few weeks a national war seemed under way.

It fell apart fast. On 29 April Pius IX told the cardinals that, as father of all Catholics, he would not wage war on Catholic Austria. Patriots felt betrayed, and neo-Guelph hopes collapsed. Ferdinand II recalled his army and later suspended his constitution. Charles Albert moved slowly, partly because he distrusted the republicans in Milan and Venice. Radetzky, reinforced, beat him at Custoza in July, and Milan was retaken. When Charles Albert tried again in March 1849, he was beaten at Novara within days and abdicated in favor of his son, Victor Emmanuel II. He died in exile in Portugal a few months later.

The Roman Republic

In Rome, the pope's chief minister, Pellegrino Rossi, was stabbed to death in November 1848, and Pius fled south to Gaeta. A constituent assembly elected by all adult men proclaimed the Roman Republic in February 1849, and Mazzini arrived to lead it as one of three triumvirs. For a few months he governed with surprising moderation. The republic's constitution, approved in July 1849, proclaimed religious freedom and abolished the death penalty. The writer and princess Cristina Trivulzio di Belgiojoso organized hospitals for the wounded, recruiting women of every class as nurses, which shocked conservatives.

The republic was destroyed not by Austria but by a French army. Louis-Napoléon Bonaparte, the new president of France, wanted Catholic votes at home and influence in Italy, and he sent troops to restore the pope. Garibaldi led the defense, but after weeks of fighting the city fell in early July. Garibaldi marched out with a few thousand volunteers, hunted by four armies. His wife Anita, who was pregnant and ill, died during the retreat.

Venice holds out

Venice resisted longest. Under siege, short of food, bombarded and struck by cholera, it surrendered to Austria in late August 1849. Everywhere the old rulers came back, many with Austrian garrisons beside them.

What 1848 taught

Patriots drew hard lessons. The pope would never lead Italy. Volunteers and barricades could take cities but not beat a professional army in the field. Without foreign help Austria could not be expelled. Only one state came out of the disaster with something new: Piedmont had a constitution, an army that had fought for Italy and a young king.

Worked example: why the Statuto survived

The Statuto Albertino was a modest charter. Only a small share of men could vote for the chamber, the king chose the senators and his ministers, and Catholicism was declared the state religion. Yet when the restored rulers elsewhere tore up their constitutions in 1849, Piedmont kept its own. Why?

Part of the answer is interest: the new king and his advisers saw that the constitution made Piedmont the natural home of Italian liberals and exiles. Part is that it was flexible. Because the document said little about how ministers related to parliament, practice could drift toward a parliamentary system without rewriting the text. The Statuto later became the constitution of the whole Kingdom of Italy and remained in force until 1948. A lesson in constitution making follows: a short, vague text can survive by being adapted, though that same vagueness later let a king hand power to a dictator without breaking its letter.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. Where did the first revolution of 1848 break out?
2. What did the people of Milan achieve in the Five Days?
3. Who led the rising that created the Republic of San Marco?
4. What did Charles Albert's slogan of 1848 express?
5. What did Pius IX announce on 29 April 1848?
6. What did the Roman Republic's 1849 constitution abolish?
7. Who destroyed the Roman Republic in 1849?
8. What did Cristina di Belgiojoso do in 1849?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia