A king who kept the constitution
Victor Emmanuel II came to the throne on a battlefield and signed a hard armistice with Austria. He was blunt, fond of hunting and no liberal by temperament. Yet he kept the Statuto, the constitution his father had granted, when every other Italian ruler abandoned theirs. Later legend claimed he heroically refused Austrian demands to scrap it; historians think the pressure was milder than the legend. When the chamber rejected the peace treaty, the king dissolved it and, in the Proclamation of Moncalieri of November 1849, urged voters to elect a more moderate one. They did. The episode showed both the limits of Piedmont's liberalism and its determination to keep a parliament.
Piedmont became a refuge for many thousands of exiles from Lombardy, Venice, Naples and the Papal States. Their presence in Turin, writing, teaching and serving in the army, turned a provincial kingdom into the center of Italian politics.
Church and state
Piedmont's liberals set out to make a modern state, and that meant clashing with the Catholic church. The Siccardi laws of 1850 abolished the separate church courts that tried clergy and ended the right of criminals to seek asylum in churches. In 1855 a further law suppressed religious orders that did not preach, teach or nurse, and sold their property. The pope responded with excommunications. These quarrels foreshadowed the much larger conflict between Italy and the papacy to come.
Cavour
The dominant figure of the decade was Count Camillo Benso di Cavour, born in Turin in 1810 to a noble family. As a young man he traveled in France and Britain and came to admire British parliamentary government, free trade and railways. He ran his family estates as a modern farmer and banker. The language that came most easily to him was French, and his written Italian was never elegant. In 1847 he cofounded a newspaper called Il Risorgimento, which gave the movement its later name.
Cavour entered the cabinet in 1850. In 1852 he made a deal, mockingly called the connubio or marriage, joining his center-right followers with the center-left led by Urbano Rattazzi. This coalition isolated the extreme right and left and made him prime minister in November 1852. He held the post, with one brief break, for most of the rest of his life.
As prime minister Cavour signed free trade treaties, built railways, modernized the port of Genoa, reformed taxes and strengthened the national bank. His goal was to make Piedmont prosperous, liberal and admired, so that Italians elsewhere would look to it and foreign governments would take it seriously. He was a master of parliamentary management and a gambler in diplomacy. Opponents saw him as a schemer who used Italian patriotism to enlarge Piedmont.
The Crimean gamble
In 1855 Piedmont joined Britain and France in the Crimean War against Russia, a war in which it had no direct interest. It sent an expeditionary force of about 15,000 men, later reinforced. They fought well at the Chernaya River in August 1855, but far more of them died of cholera than in battle. The point was not Russia. Cavour wanted a seat at the peace conference and the goodwill of Britain and France. At the Congress of Paris in 1856 he was allowed to raise the "Italian question" and criticize Austrian and papal rule. He gained no territory, but he made Italy a European issue.
From Mazzini to the monarchy
Meanwhile, more republicans despaired of Mazzini's failed risings. In 1857 Daniele Manin and others founded the National Society, which aimed at a united Italy under the House of Savoy. Its slogan was "Italy and Victor Emmanuel". Garibaldi joined it. The shift mattered: many democrats now accepted a monarchy as the price of unity.
Then, in January 1858, an Italian revolutionary named Felice Orsini threw bombs at Napoleon III's carriage outside the Paris opera. The emperor survived, but eight bystanders were killed and many wounded. From prison Orsini wrote to the emperor, begging him to free Italy from Austria. He was executed in March, but his letter was published with official approval. Napoleon III, who had been a conspirator in Italy in his youth, now wanted to act.
Worked example: the secret meeting at Plombières
In July 1858 Cavour traveled in disguise to the spa town of Plombières in eastern France for a secret meeting with Napoleon III. Over several hours they agreed a plan. Piedmont would provoke Austria into a war that looked defensive. France would join with a large army. Afterward Italy would be reorganized: a Kingdom of Upper Italy under Victor Emmanuel, including Lombardy and Venetia; a kingdom in central Italy; the pope keeping Rome; and Naples left alone. The four states would form a confederation with the pope as its president. In return France would receive Savoy and Nice, and the king's fifteen-year-old daughter Clotilde would marry the emperor's thirty-six-year-old cousin.
The plan is revealing. It was not a design for a united Italy, and it was not a people's movement. It was a dynastic and diplomatic bargain between two governments, using a girl's marriage and the transfer of other people's homelands as bargaining chips. Yet it set in motion events that went far beyond what either man intended. Students of history should note how often outcomes escape the plans of those who launch them.
