Skip to main content

The charcoal burners

The first challenge to the restored order came from secret societies. The best known were the Carbonari, whose name means charcoal burners. They borrowed rituals and ranks from freemasonry, swore members to secrecy and drew in army officers, lawyers, students and minor nobles. Their aims were vague and varied from lodge to lodge, but most wanted constitutions that limited the power of kings.

In July 1820 officers in the Kingdom of the Two Sicilies rose and forced King Ferdinand I to grant a constitution. In March 1821 liberals in Piedmont tried the same. Both movements were short lived. Austrian armies crushed them with the blessing of the other great powers, who met at Laibach in 1821 and agreed that revolution anywhere threatened them all. A second wave in 1831 brought risings in Modena, Parma and the papal province of Romagna. Again Austrian troops marched in. In Modena the conspirator Ciro Menotti was hanged.

The lesson seemed clear. Local revolts led by a few officers could not beat Austria, and they could not win ordinary people, who often had no idea what a constitution was.

Mazzini: the nation as a mission

Giuseppe Mazzini, born in Genoa in 1805, drew a different lesson. He had been a member of the Carbonari and thought they failed because they were secretive, elitist and unclear. Italy, he argued, must be made by the Italian people themselves, through education and insurrection, and it must be a single, unitary republic, not a league of princes. His motto was "Thought and Action", meaning that ideas were worthless unless they led to deeds.

Mazzini spent most of his adult life in exile, much of it in London. He wrote endlessly, ran networks of followers across Europe and the Americas, and organized one rising after another. Almost all of them failed, and many young men died in them. Critics then and since called him a dreamer who sent others to their deaths. Admirers answer that his propaganda made the idea of a united Italy familiar to a whole generation and that later, more practical politicians reaped what he sowed.

The moderates' alternatives

Many educated Italians wanted change but feared Mazzini's republic and his methods. In the 1840s they found their own writers.

  • Vincenzo Gioberti, a Piedmontese priest, published On the Moral and Civil Primacy of the Italians in 1843. He proposed a confederation of the existing Italian states under the presidency of the pope. His followers were called neo-Guelphs, after the medieval party that backed the papacy.
  • Cesare Balbo, a Piedmontese noble, answered in 1844 with The Hopes of Italy. He doubted Austria could be beaten in battle and suggested it might give up its Italian lands if it were compensated with territory in the Balkans as the Ottoman Empire declined. He looked to Piedmont to lead.
  • Carlo Cattaneo, a Milanese economist, distrusted both popes and kings. He wanted a federal republic, a United States of Italy, in which each region governed itself.

These plans disagreed about almost everything except the need to loosen Austria's grip. Note that none of them, in 1845, expected the outcome that actually came: a centralized kingdom under the House of Savoy.

Novels and operas

National feeling also grew through culture. Alessandro Manzoni's novel The Betrothed, set in Lombardy under Spanish rule, became the most widely read Italian book of the century. For the revised edition of 1840 to 1842 Manzoni rewrote the whole text into the Florentine usage of educated speakers, a choice he described as rinsing his clothes in the Arno. He hoped to give Italians a common modern prose. Giuseppe Verdi's operas, such as Nabucco of 1842, were later remembered as patriotic anthems. Historians now debate how political audiences found them at the time; some of the legend was built after unification.

Women played a part in this cultural world that the heroic story long ignored. In Milan, Countess Clara Maffei ran a salon from the 1830s where writers, musicians and conspirators met, argued and passed news. Mothers taught children patriotic songs, and wives of exiles kept networks alive by smuggling letters. Such work rarely appears in battle histories, yet it was how ideas moved from books into families.

Worked example: the Bandiera brothers

Attilio and Emilio Bandiera were Venetian-born officers in the Austrian navy who became followers of Mazzini. In June 1844, acting on rumors that Calabria was ready to revolt, they landed near Crotone with about twenty companions. The expected rising did not happen. Local peasants did not join them, and some helped the authorities. The group was captured, and nine of them, including both brothers, were shot at Cosenza in July 1844.

The episode caused a scandal far away. It emerged that the British government had been secretly opening Mazzini's letters in London, and many believed the information had reached Austria and Naples. Whatever the truth of that, the Bandiera affair shows the pattern of the period: brave, idealistic men acting on hope rather than evidence, a population that did not share their dream, and harsh repression. It also made the brothers martyrs, and martyrs were part of how the national idea spread.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What does the name Carbonari mean?
2. What happened to the risings of 1820 and 1821?
3. What form of state did Mazzini want for Italy?
4. What did Mazzini's motto Thought and Action mean?
5. What did Gioberti propose in 1843?
6. How did Balbo think Austria might be persuaded to leave?
7. What kind of Italy did Carlo Cattaneo favor?
8. What did Manzoni change in his novel's 1840 to 1842 edition?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia