Skip to main content

A geographical expression

In 1847 the Austrian chancellor Prince Metternich wrote that Italy was a geographical expression. He meant it as a put-down and as a statement of fact. There was a peninsula called Italy, with a shared past and a celebrated literature, but there was no Italian state, no Italian army, no Italian flag and no Italian government. Many of its people had never thought of themselves as Italians at all. They were Neapolitans, Sicilians, Venetians, Genoese or simply people of their own town and valley.

The story of how this patchwork became a single kingdom between 1859 and 1871 is called the Risorgimento, a word that means rising again, or revival. The name itself carries an argument. It suggests that Italy had once been great, under Rome and in the Renaissance, and only needed to be woken up. Historians today treat that as a story the nationalists told, not a simple fact. A nation, they point out, can be built as much as revived.

The map of 1815

After Napoleon's defeat, the Congress of Vienna redrew the peninsula to keep revolution and France out. The result looked like this:

  • The Kingdom of Sardinia, ruled by the House of Savoy, held Piedmont, Savoy, Nice, the island of Sardinia and now the former republic of Genoa. Its capital was Turin, and it is usually called Piedmont or Piedmont-Sardinia.
  • The kingdom of Lombardy-Venetia, the richest part of the north, was ruled directly by the Austrian Empire.
  • Small duchies in the center, Tuscany, Modena and Parma, were ruled by relatives or allies of the Austrian emperor. Parma went to Marie Louise, Napoleon's Austrian wife.
  • The Papal States stretched across the middle of the peninsula from Rome to Bologna, ruled by the pope as a monarch.
  • The Kingdom of the Two Sicilies, the largest state, covered the south and Sicily and was ruled by a branch of the Bourbons from Naples.

Austria was the keystone of this order. Its armies could march into any state that faced a rising, and its diplomats treated the whole peninsula as part of their sphere. Any project to unite Italy would therefore have to defeat or outmaneuver a great power.

Many tongues, one literary language

Ordinary people spoke local languages that differed as much as Spanish differs from Portuguese. A peasant from Bergamo and a fisherman from Palermo could barely understand each other. What united the educated was a written language based on Florentine Tuscan, the language of Dante, Petrarch and Boccaccio. It was a language of books, law and the church, not of the kitchen or the market.

How many people actually spoke it? The numbers are estimates and disputed. One famous calculation puts the share who could speak standard Italian at unification at about 2.5 percent, and even generous estimates stay at no more than about a tenth. The ruling family of Piedmont spoke French and Piedmontese at court. National feeling in this period was strongest among a thin layer of students, writers, lawyers, army officers and merchants.

What Napoleon left behind

French rule from the 1790s to 1814 had shaken the old order. Napoleon created a Kingdom of Italy in 1805 with its capital at Milan, though it covered only the north and center and was firmly under French control. French administrators abolished feudal privileges in many places, sold church lands, introduced a civil code, built roads and recruited Italians into the same armies. Thousands of young men learned to serve in units that were called Italian.

The restored rulers of 1815 tore up much of this, but not all of it. Some kept the codes and the more efficient tax systems. More important, a generation now remembered that the old borders were not eternal. A map that had been redrawn once could be redrawn again.

Was unity inevitable?

Looking back, unification can seem bound to happen. In 1815 it was not. Most Italian rulers wanted to keep their thrones. The pope had religious reasons to keep his territory. Most peasants cared about land, taxes, food and their priests far more than about a national flag. The idea of a single Italian state was a minority dream, and even its supporters disagreed about whether it should be a republic, a monarchy or a federation.

Worked example: a journey from Turin to Naples

Imagine a silk merchant setting out from Turin for Naples in 1830. Before reaching the sea he would pass from Piedmont into the Duchy of Parma or the Austrian lands, then into Modena or Tuscany, then into the Papal States and finally into the Kingdom of the Two Sicilies. At each border he would show his passport, have his goods inspected and pay customs. He would change money, since each state minted its own coins, and he would deal with different weights and measures. A police officer in the Papal States might search his luggage for forbidden books.

The journey shows why some practical people, not only poets, came to favor unity. Merchants and landowners in the north wanted bigger markets and fewer tolls. Yet the same example shows the limits of the cause. The innkeepers, carters and farmers he met along the way lived inside their own small worlds and had little reason to care which flag flew over the customs house. Building Italy would mean persuading or compelling them.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did Metternich call Italy in 1847?
2. What does the word Risorgimento mean?
3. Which family ruled the Kingdom of Sardinia?
4. Where was the capital of Piedmont-Sardinia?
5. Who ruled Lombardy-Venetia after 1815?
6. Which dynasty ruled the Kingdom of the Two Sicilies?
7. Literary Italian was based on which local language?
8. What do generous estimates say about standard Italian speakers in 1861?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia