Skip to main content

John II returned to France after Brétigny while his ransom was being paid, leaving hostages in England. When one of those hostages, his son Louis of Anjou, broke his word and escaped, John went back to captivity in London, and he died there in 1364. His son, the former Dauphin, became Charles V. Physically frail and no warrior, Charles has been remembered as "the Wise," and he was the most effective French king of the war.

Rebuilding a kingdom

Charles began with money and order. He made taxes such as the hearth tax and sales duties regular, organized their collection, and used the income to pay troops, fortify towns and repair castles. He also found a way to export trouble. Many free companies were persuaded to march into Castile in 1366 to fight in a civil war there, led by a Breton captain named Bertrand du Guesclin.

The Black Prince overreaches

The Castilian civil war drew in the English too. The Black Prince, now ruling Aquitaine, backed King Peter of Castile and in 1367 won a great victory at Nájera in Castile, where du Guesclin was captured. But the campaign ruined the prince's health and finances. To pay his debts he imposed a hearth tax on Aquitaine in 1368, and powerful Gascon lords, led by the Count of Armagnac and the Lord of Albret, refused to pay.

They took their case to Paris. Under the Treaty of Brétigny, Charles V should have had no authority over Aquitaine at all. But the formal renunciations had never been exchanged, so Charles could argue he was still the duchy's overlord. He accepted the appeals and summoned the prince to his court. The prince refused, and in 1369 the war resumed, set off when Gascon lords appealed to Charles V against the Black Prince's hearth tax.

Fighting by not fighting

Charles had learned from Crécy and Poitiers. His strategy was to avoid pitched battles, wear down English raids and retake castles one by one. When English armies rode out on chevauchée, the French shut themselves inside walled towns, stripped the countryside of food, shadowed the raiders, and picked off stragglers. Meanwhile they besieged English-held strongholds, often buying their surrender. Charles chose du Guesclin, a minor Breton noble with a talent for war, as Constable of France in 1370, the highest military office in the kingdom and an unusual honor for a man of his modest rank.

At sea, France's ally Castile sent war galleys that destroyed an English fleet off La Rochelle in 1372, weakening English control of the coast. On land the English position crumbled. In 1370 the Black Prince sacked the city of Limoges after it went over to France. Froissart reported some three thousand dead, but modern historians think the number was far smaller; the episode shows how chroniclers could magnify a story.

A changing cast

The great figures of the first phase died within a few years of each other. The Black Prince died in 1376, Edward III in 1377. Charles V and du Guesclin both died in 1380. By then England held little more than Calais and the coast of Gascony around Bordeaux and Bayonne, along with a few coastal fortresses such as Brest and Cherbourg.

Both thrones then passed to boys: Richard II in England and Charles VI in France. Neither government could afford much war. In 1396 the two kings agreed to a long truce, sealed when Richard II married Isabella, the young daughter of Charles VI. Many English nobles thought the peace shameful, and Richard's policy added to the resentment that led to his overthrow in 1399 by his cousin, who became Henry IV.

Worked example: John of Gaunt's long march, 1373

In 1373 Edward III's son John of Gaunt led perhaps nine thousand men from Calais on a great chevauchée across France toward Bordeaux. It should have been the classic English campaign: burn the land, provoke the French into attacking, then destroy them with archers.

The French refused to play. They closed the town gates, removed food from the route, and followed the English at a distance, attacking foragers and outlying groups. No battle came. As the army pushed south into the uplands of central France in autumn, horses died in large numbers, men went hungry, and many fell sick. Gaunt reached Bordeaux around Christmas with a battered, partly unhorsed army, having captured little of lasting value.

Some French nobles complained that refusing battle was unworthy of knights. The results answered them. A raid that wins no battle and takes no fortress only costs the raider. Charles V's strategy turned the English formula against itself: the defensive battle needs an enemy willing to attack, and Charles simply would not supply one. The lesson reaches beyond medieval France. A strategy can be strong because the other side expects you to behave in a certain way; take away that expectation and the strength disappears.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What set off the renewal of war in 1369?
2. Why could Charles V claim he still had authority over Aquitaine?
3. What was Charles V's main military strategy?
4. What office did Bertrand du Guesclin receive in 1370?
5. Where did the Black Prince win a great victory in 1367?
6. Where did a Castilian fleet defeat the English in 1372?
7. By 1380, what did England still hold in France?
8. What sealed the long Anglo-French truce of 1396?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia