In August 1392, riding through a forest near Le Mans, Charles VI of France suddenly drew his sword and attacked his own companions, killing several before he was restrained. It was the first of many bouts of mental illness that would afflict him for thirty years. In some episodes he did not recognize his wife; in one, according to reports, he believed he was made of glass. Between attacks he was lucid and ruled. During them, someone else had to.
Princes at each other's throats
The king's illness opened a struggle for power among the royal princes. On one side stood his brother, Louis, Duke of Orléans. On the other stood his uncle, Philip the Bold, Duke of Burgundy, and after 1404 Philip's son, John the Fearless. Control of the king meant control of the royal treasury. In November 1407, men hired by John the Fearless murdered Louis of Orléans in a Paris street. John openly admitted the deed and had a theologian argue that killing a tyrant was lawful.
France slid into civil war. The Orléans party became known as the Armagnacs, after Count Bernard of Armagnac, father-in-law of the murdered duke's son. The Burgundians were popular in Paris and strong in the north, where the dukes also ruled Flanders. Both sides sought English help, and both offered English kings territory in return.
Henry V
In England, Henry IV had seized the throne in 1399, and his son, Henry V, who became king in 1413, needed to show the new Lancastrian dynasty had God's favor. He revived the claim to the French crown. In August 1415 he landed in Normandy and laid siege to the port of Harfleur. It fell after five weeks, but dysentery killed or disabled a large part of his army. Henry decided to march overland to Calais anyway.
Agincourt
A French army blocked his path near the village of Agincourt. On 25 October 1415 the two armies faced each other across a field of freshly ploughed land, soaked by rain, with woods on either side. The French were more numerous, but the ground worked against them. Their men-at-arms advanced on foot through deep mud on a narrow field hemmed in by woods, under heavy arrow fire, and pressed together so tightly they could barely lift their weapons. Lightly armed English archers joined in the slaughter with mallets and swords. When a fresh attack seemed to threaten, Henry ordered many prisoners killed, a decision that troubled even some contemporaries. Among the captives who survived was Charles, Duke of Orléans, who spent twenty-five years in England and became one of the finest poets of his age.
How many fought? Traditional accounts give perhaps six thousand English against three or four times as many French. The historian Anne Curry, studying pay records, argued the gap was much smaller, perhaps nine thousand against twelve thousand. Other scholars dispute her figures. All agree the English were outnumbered and won decisively.
Conquest, not raiding
Henry's next move broke with the past. From 1417 he set out on a methodical conquest of Normandy, aiming to occupy and govern it rather than raid it. Town after town was besieged and garrisoned. Rouen held out for six months and surrendered in January 1419 after its people starved. Normans who swore loyalty kept their property; those who refused lost it.
A murder on a bridge
In September 1419, John the Fearless met the Dauphin Charles, heir of Charles VI, on a bridge at Montereau to discuss an alliance. The Dauphin's men cut John down. His son, Philip the Good, took revenge the only way he could: Burgundy allied with England. In May 1420 the Treaty of Troyes made Henry V heir to the French throne. He married Charles VI's daughter Catherine, became regent of France, and the Dauphin was disinherited. Henry died in August 1422, aged about thirty-five; Charles VI died seven weeks later. An infant, Henry VI, was now proclaimed king of both England and France.
Worked example: reading a battlefield
Why did a bigger, better-armored army lose so badly at Agincourt? Take the factors one at a time.
Ground: the field narrowed toward the English line between two woods. The French front ranks were squeezed as they advanced, losing the room to swing a sword. Weather: rain on ploughed earth made the mud heavy enough to tire a man in full armor before he reached the enemy. Weapons: arrows did not need to pierce plate armor to do damage; they killed horses, struck faces and joints, and forced men to lower their heads. Command: the French leadership was divided, with great lords competing for the honor of the front line, so many of the most important nobles crowded into the first attack. Morale: the English, sick and hungry, had no way home except through the French army.
No single cause explains the result. The lesson for any reader of history is to be suspicious of one-word answers, such as "the longbow," and to look instead at how several conditions came together on one wet day.
