Skip to main content

Democracy promises that each citizen counts equally. Yet in many democracies the people deciding long-term questions are mostly older, while those who will live longest with the results are underrepresented or cannot vote at all. This final level looks at who holds political voice across the life course, and at proposals to change it.

The age gap in politics

Two gaps stand out. Younger adults vote less often than older ones in most democracies, though the size of the gap varies a great deal. And legislatures are much older than the populations they serve. Surveys by the Inter-Parliamentary Union have found that people under 30 hold under 3 percent of seats in the world's parliaments, though they make up a far larger share of adults.

Some writers warn of gerontocracy, rule by the old in the interests of the old. The evidence is more mixed than the slogan suggests. Older people often support spending on schools and on their grandchildren's prospects, and their views differ by class, region and party as much as by age. Research on transfers within families finds that in many rich countries, money and time flow mostly from older relatives to younger ones, through gifts, inheritances and child care.

Lowering the voting age

Most democracies lowered the voting age from 21 to 18 around 1970. A smaller movement now seeks to lower it to 16. Brazil has allowed optional voting from 16 since its 1988 constitution. In 2007 Austria became the first country in the European Union to lower the voting age to 16 for national elections. Scotland let 16 and 17 year olds vote in its 2014 independence referendum and later in its own elections, and Malta followed for national elections in 2018.

The evidence from Austria answered a key worry. Opponents argued that 16 year olds lacked the maturity to vote well. Studies of Austrian voters found that 16 and 17 year olds chose parties matching their own views about as well as older voters did. A second argument concerns habit. Voting is partly a habit formed by doing it, and 16 year olds usually still live at home and attend school, where parents and teachers can help them take part. Supporters argue that voting first at 16 builds a lasting habit of turnout better than starting at 18, when many young people are moving away. Early evidence from Austria and Scotland suggests that 16 and 17 year olds often turn out at higher rates than 18 to 20 year olds, though not as high as older adults.

Opponents raise fair points. Many legal rights, such as signing contracts, begin at 18, so drawing the line at 16 can seem inconsistent. Some worry that young voters may be swayed by parents or teachers. Defenders reply that every age line is somewhat arbitrary and that adults are swayed by others too.

Votes for children?

A more radical proposal came in 1986 from the demographer Paul Demeny. Demeny voting would let parents cast extra votes on behalf of their children, so that the interests of the young would carry weight in elections. Germany's parliament debated versions of the idea in the 2000s and rejected them. The main objection to Demeny voting is that it breaks the rule of one person, one vote, giving some adults more power than others, with no guarantee that parents would vote in their children's interests rather than their own.

Other channels

Voting is not the only way to be heard. Youth councils, youth seats on citizens' assemblies, and duties for governments to consult young people all add voice without changing who may vote. Their weakness is that advice can be ignored.

The underlying principle is easy to state and hard to apply: each person has equal worth at every stage of life. Fairness between generations does not mean every age group always gets what it wants. It means that no group, whether young, old or not yet born, is treated as a mere means to the comfort of another.

Worked example: a city considers votes at 16

A city council is debating whether to let 16 and 17 year olds vote in local elections. Turnout among residents under 25 is low, and the council is far older than the city it governs. Supporters cite the Austrian evidence that young voters match their choices to their views, and the habit argument: voting first while living at home might raise turnout for decades. Opponents worry about pressure from parents and the oddity of voting before being allowed to sign a lease. A Demeny-style scheme would break one person, one vote. A middle path is to lower the voting age for local elections only, pair it with civic education in schools, and add youth seats on advisory panels, then measure turnout among the new voters over several elections. That approach treats the change as an experiment to be judged on evidence, which suits the subject: fairness between generations is best pursued in the open, with every affected group able to follow the reasoning.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What share of parliamentary seats do people under 30 hold, per IPU surveys?
2. Which way do money and time mostly flow within families in many rich countries?
3. What did Austria do in 2007?
4. What did studies of young Austrian voters find?
5. What is the habit argument for votes at 16?
6. What would Demeny voting do?
7. What is the main objection to Demeny voting?
8. Which argument against votes at 16 does the level mention?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia