Politicians often warn that public debt is a burden "on our children and grandchildren." Others reply that a nation's debt is mostly owed to its own citizens and is far less dangerous than it sounds. Both claims contain some truth.
Explicit and implicit debt
Public debt is the total a government owes from past borrowing. That is explicit debt, written down in bonds. Governments also make promises that are not counted as debt, such as pensions and health care for people who are working now. Implicit debt consists of future obligations, such as promised pensions, that are not recorded as borrowing. In many aging countries, unfunded pension promises are larger than the official national debt.
"We owe it to ourselves"
In 1943 the economist Abba Lerner argued that a debt held by a nation's own citizens is not a burden on the nation as a whole. When the government repays, it taxes some citizens and pays others; the country as a whole is no poorer. Lerner argued that a nationally held debt is owed to ourselves and does not make the nation poorer.
The economist James Buchanan replied in 1958. People who buy government bonds do so voluntarily, in exchange for interest, so they make no sacrifice. The real cost falls later, on taxpayers who must pay interest and principal without having enjoyed the spending. Buchanan held that the burden of debt falls on the future taxpayers who must repay it, so borrowing really does shift costs across time. Later economists added another channel: if government borrowing absorbs savings that would otherwise fund private investment, future workers inherit less productive capital.
Ricardian equivalence
In 1974 the American economist Robert Barro offered a surprising argument. Suppose the government cuts taxes today and borrows, planning to raise taxes later. If parents care about their children, they will save the tax cut to help their heirs pay the coming bill. Ricardian equivalence holds that people save to offset future taxes, so replacing taxes with borrowing changes little. The idea is named for the nineteenth-century economist David Ricardo, who described it and then doubted that people really behave that way. Most evidence agrees with Ricardo's doubt: people offset some government borrowing, but far from all of it.
Counting by cohort
In 1991 the economists Alan Auerbach, Jagadeesh Gokhale and Laurence Kotlikoff introduced generational accounting. Generational accounting estimates the lifetime taxes paid minus benefits received by each birth cohort under current policy. If present policies cannot be sustained, the method shows how much more future-born cohorts would have to pay. Critics reply that its results swing widely with assumptions about growth and interest, and that it tends to count schools and research as mere spending rather than gifts to the young.
When interest is low
In 2019 the French economist Olivier Blanchard, in an address to the American Economic Association, stressed a fact with large consequences: for long stretches of history, the interest rate on government debt has been below the economy's growth rate. When the interest rate is below the growth rate, a debt can shrink relative to the economy without new taxes, so its burden on the future may be smaller than feared. Interest rates rose sharply from 2022, a reminder that this condition can change.
A cautionary tale concerns a famous finding. In 2010 Carmen Reinhart and Kenneth Rogoff reported that growth slowed sharply once public debt passed 90 percent of national output. In 2013 a graduate student, Thomas Herndon, and two colleagues found a spreadsheet error and debatable choices in how the data were weighted. The corrected analysis found a weaker link between debt and growth, with no sharp cliff at 90 percent.
What the money buys
Many economists conclude that the fairness of debt depends heavily on its use. Borrowing to invest in things that will benefit the future is easier to justify than borrowing to pay for current consumption. Britain's "golden rule" from 1997 allowed borrowing over the economic cycle only to invest. Germany's debt brake, adopted in 2009, capped structural deficits tightly; its critics argued it left bridges, railways and schools in disrepair, which is also a burden passed to the young. In 2025 Germany loosened the brake for defense and created a large infrastructure fund.
Worked example: Norway's oil money
When Norway began earning large oil revenues, it faced a generational question: oil is finite, so who should benefit? Rather than spending the money as it came in, Norway placed it in a state fund invested abroad, now one of the largest in the world. A fiscal rule lets the government spend roughly the fund's expected real return each year, currently set at 3 percent of its value, leaving the principal for future Norwegians. This turns a one-time resource into a lasting income, and it stands in sharp contrast to Nauru's lost trust fund. It reflects Rawls's concern with saving: the present takes its part without consuming the future's share. Critics in Norway argue that the rule can be too cautious when schools and hospitals need money now, and that investing in the country's own railways and research would also serve future citizens. Even a model of prudence across generations must still decide what counts as an investment.
