Skip to main content

In 1646 almost no one on Parliament's side wanted to end the monarchy. The aim was a settlement that would bind the king to limits. Charles, however, believed that his enemies needed him more than he needed any of them, and that by delay he could split them. In June 1647 a detachment of the army took him from Parliament's custody, and for months the king negotiated with Parliament, the army and the Scots at once, promising different things to each.

The second war

In November 1647 Charles escaped from Hampton Court and fled to the Isle of Wight, where he was held at Carisbrooke Castle. There, in December, he signed the Engagement with a group of Scottish nobles. In it the Scots agreed to invade England on his behalf, and he promised to establish Presbyterianism in England for a trial period of three years. In 1648 royalist risings broke out in Wales, Kent and Essex, where rebels held Colchester through a long summer siege, and a Scottish army marched south. In August Cromwell defeated the Scots at Preston in Lancashire, and Colchester surrendered soon after.

This Second Civil War changed how many soldiers saw the king. The first war could be blamed on evil counsellors. Now Charles himself had brought a foreign army into England after defeat, and to the army's religious radicals that looked like defiance of God's verdict. At a prayer meeting at Windsor in spring 1648 officers resolved that, if they won, they would call Charles Stuart, "that man of blood", to account for the blood he had shed.

Pride's Purge and the Rump

Parliament, alarmed by the army, reopened talks with the king at Newport on the Isle of Wight and in early December voted to continue them. On 6 December 1648 soldiers under Colonel Thomas Pride stood at the door of the Commons with a list and turned away or arrested members who favored a treaty. The members who were left became known as the Rump. On 4 January 1649 the Rump declared that the Commons, as chosen by the people, held supreme power in the nation, and that its acts had the force of law without king or Lords. Two days later, without the Lords, it set up a High Court of Justice to try the king.

The trial

The trial opened on 20 January 1649 in Westminster Hall. Its president was John Bradshaw, a lawyer, who is said to have worn a hat lined with metal in case of attack. Many of those named as judges stayed away, Fairfax among them. When the charge was read, accusing Charles of levying war against his people, the king refused to plead. He asked again and again by what lawful authority he had been brought there. On 27 January he was sentenced to death as a tyrant, traitor, murderer and public enemy, and fifty nine commissioners signed the death warrant.

On 30 January 1649 Charles walked out through a window onto a scaffold outside the Banqueting House in Whitehall. In his last speech he insisted that a subject and a sovereign were "clean different things", and that the people's liberty lay in having good laws, not a share in government. A young witness later recalled that the crowd let out a groan such as he had never heard before.

A republic and a royal martyr

In March 1649 the Rump abolished the office of king and the House of Lords, and in May it declared England a Commonwealth and free state, governed by Parliament and a Council of State. Within days of the execution a book appeared called Eikon Basilike, the King's Image, presented as the king's own prayers and meditations from captivity. It went through dozens of editions in a year. The dead king became a martyr far more persuasive than the living one had been, and his execution day was kept as a solemn fast for nearly two centuries after the monarchy returned.

Worked example: was the trial lawful?

Weigh the two arguments as their best defenders would. Charles's case was simple and strong. No English court had ever tried a king. All courts acted in the king's name, so a court that tried him had no lawful source. The Commons that created it had been purged by soldiers, and the Lords had refused their consent. On that reading, the trial was force dressed up as justice.

The prosecutor, John Cook, answered that the king had been trusted with a limited power to govern by law for the good of the people. A ruler who made war on the people he was trusted to protect had broken that trust and could be judged like anyone else. The authority of the court, on this view, came from the people through their representatives, and the rule that no one is above the law applied to kings too. Yet the trial was also, plainly, the act of an army minority. Both points are true, and the tension between them shaped the republic that followed: it rested on popular sovereignty in theory and on soldiers in practice.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did Charles promise the Scots in the Engagement of 1647?
2. Where did Cromwell defeat the invading Scottish army in August 1648?
3. Why did the Second Civil War harden many soldiers against Charles?
4. What did the Rump declare on 4 January 1649?
5. Who presided over the trial of Charles I?
6. How many commissioners signed the king's death warrant?
7. What was Eikon Basilike presented as?
8. Where was Charles I executed?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia