Skip to main content

Before 1640 printing in England was tightly licensed, and political news of home affairs was hard to publish. When Star Chamber fell and the machinery of censorship broke down, the presses ran free. A London bookseller, George Thomason, set out to collect everything he could find. His collection, now in the British Library, holds about twenty two thousand pamphlets, newspapers and books printed between 1640 and 1661, and it shows a society arguing with itself in print. From late 1641 weekly newsbooks reported the proceedings of Parliament, and soon each side had its own: the royalist Mercurius Aulicus from Oxford, the parliamentarian Mercurius Britanicus from London.

Which church?

With bishops abolished and the prayer book banned, the question was what should replace them. In 1643 Parliament summoned the Westminster Assembly, a body of clergy and laymen charged with reforming the doctrine, worship and government of the church. Its Confession of Faith of 1646 would long outlive the revolution in Scotland and among Presbyterians abroad. The Assembly's majority, and most of Parliament, wanted a national Presbyterian church, governed by elected elders and synods, which would still require everyone to belong.

Against them stood the Independents, who held that each gathered congregation of believers should govern itself, and who wanted some freedom for other godly Protestants. Beyond them were sects that believed in adult baptism, or that the end of the world was near, or that the Spirit could speak through any believer. The New Model Army, full of such men, was a stronghold of Independency. To Presbyterians, toleration meant anarchy; to Independents, a compulsory Presbyterian church was simply a new tyranny.

The Levellers

Out of this ferment came a political movement. Its leaders were the London pamphleteer John Lilburne, known as Freeborn John, who had been whipped and pilloried under Charles and imprisoned again under Parliament, along with Richard Overton and William Walwyn. Their enemies called them Levellers, implying that they would level property, a charge they rejected. What they demanded was a new constitution resting on the consent of the people. They wore sea green ribbons, organized petitions with thousands of signatures, and in 1649 women supporters petitioned Parliament in their own name for Lilburne's release, and were told, in effect, to go home.

Their key text was the Agreement of the People, first drafted in 1647. It proposed regular parliaments elected from districts based on population, and it listed rights that no parliament could touch, among them freedom of religion, freedom from forced military service, and equality before the law. It was meant to be signed by the people themselves, as a founding compact above ordinary law.

The world turned upside down

Other groups went further. In April 1649 a small band led by Gerrard Winstanley began to dig and plant the common land on St George's Hill in Surrey. These Diggers held that the earth should be shared as common land for all to work; Winstanley wrote that God made the earth "a common treasury" for all. Local landowners and soldiers broke up their settlements within a year. Fifth Monarchists expected the imminent rule of Christ and his saints. The early Quakers, gathered by George Fox, held that God's light could speak directly within every person. They refused to remove their hats before social superiors or to swear oaths, and they let women preach. To many contemporaries such sects proved that the old order was collapsing.

Worked example: the debates at Putney

By 1647 Parliament wanted to disband much of the army, largely unpaid, and send the rest to Ireland. The regiments elected representatives called agitators to speak for them, and the army formed a General Council where officers and agitators sat together. From 28 October to early November 1647 the Council met in St Mary's Church at Putney, near London, to debate the Agreement of the People. A secretary, William Clarke, took the speeches down in shorthand. His manuscript lay unknown until it was found at Worcester College, Oxford, and published in 1891, which is why the debates read so vividly today.

The sharpest clash was over the vote. Henry Ireton, Cromwell's son in law, argued that only those with a permanent fixed interest in the kingdom, meaning land or a recognized place in a town's trade, should choose its lawmakers; otherwise a majority without property might vote property away. Edward Sexby, an agitator, answered that thousands of soldiers had risked their lives for the kingdom and asked whether they had fought only to be told they had no right in it. Apply the ideas above. Both men claimed to defend liberty. For Ireton liberty was protected by property and settled law; for the agitators it was founded in each person's birthright. The debate ended without agreement, and in mid November Cromwell and Fairfax put down a mutiny at Corkbush Field in Hertfordshire. Universal manhood suffrage would not come for more than two centuries.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What does the Thomason collection preserve?
2. What was the Westminster Assembly charged with?
3. What did the Independents believe about church government?
4. What did the Agreement of the People propose?
5. What did the Diggers believe about land?
6. What did the Levellers' enemies imply by that name?
7. How did early Quakers defy the customs of rank?
8. What new form of print appeared weekly from late 1641?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia