After the Third Crusade, Western leaders drew a strategic lesson. Jerusalem could be won, but not held, while the sultan in Cairo controlled the wealth of the Nile. So the thirteenth century's great eastern crusades went to Egypt. They brought a saint into the sultan's tent, an excommunicated emperor into Jerusalem and a king into captivity.
The Fifth Crusade
Planners of the Fifth Crusade, launched in 1217, made Egypt the target because it was the wealthy base of Ayyubid power, the dynasty Saladin had founded. The crusaders besieged the Nile port of Damietta and took it in 1219 after a long siege, with contingents from Frisia, Hungary, Austria and Italy in the camp, that killed most of its inhabitants through famine and disease. Desperate, the sultan al-Kamil offered to trade Jerusalem for Damietta, but the papal legate Pelagius refused, hoping for more. In 1221 the crusaders marched toward Cairo just as the Nile flood rose; al-Kamil opened the sluices, the army was trapped in the mud and had to surrender Damietta to escape.
During the siege, Francis of Assisi crossed the lines in 1219 to preach to the sultan al-Kamil, who received him courteously, listened and sent him back unharmed. No conversion followed, but the meeting became one of the most retold episodes of the age.
An emperor without a battle
Frederick II, the emperor who was both German king and king of Sicily, had vowed to crusade and delayed for years. Pope Gregory IX excommunicated him. Frederick went anyway, and in 1229 Frederick II regained Jerusalem by treaty with al-Kamil, without a battle. The sultan, facing rivals in his own family, handed over the city, with the Muslim holy places on the Temple Mount left in Muslim hands. Frederick crowned himself in the Church of the Holy Sepulchre. Many Christians were outraged that an excommunicate had made a deal with an infidel, and many Muslims were outraged that the sultan had given away the holy city. The arrangement lasted fifteen years. In 1244 a Khwarazmian Turkish army, driven west by the Mongols, sacked Jerusalem, and it never returned to Latin rule.
Saint Louis and the Mamluks
Louis IX of France, later canonized, was the most devout crusading king. He spent years preparing, landed in Egypt in 1249 and took Damietta again. Advancing on Mansurah, his army was cut off by Egyptian forces, and Louis IX was captured in Egypt in 1250 and freed for a huge ransom. He then spent four years in the Holy Land rebuilding fortifications.
Louis's campaign triggered a revolution in Cairo. The sultan's elite troops were mamluks, soldiers bought as enslaved boys, mostly Turks from the steppe, and trained as cavalry. In 1250 they murdered the new sultan and seized power themselves, founding a state that would rule Egypt and Syria for more than 250 years. The Mamluks halted the Mongols in 1260 and then turned on the Franks. Their sultan Baybars took fortress after fortress, and in 1268 Baybars captured Antioch, ending a crusader state that had stood since 1098. Louis IX launched one last crusade and died at Tunis in 1270. In 1291 the last major Frankish cities on the mainland fell.
The long afterlife
Crusading did not end in 1291. Cyprus remained a Latin kingdom, and the Hospitallers made islands their base. As the Ottoman Turks advanced into the Balkans, crusades turned to defending Europe. At Varna in 1444 a crusading army was destroyed and its leader, King Władysław of Poland and Hungary, was killed. Leagues of Christian states, blessed by popes, fought the Ottomans at sea into the 1500s. The Hospitallers held the island of Rhodes for two centuries, and crusade preaching and crusade taxes became a routine part of church life. Kings sometimes collected crusade taxes and then spent the money on their own wars at home. Many people who never left home took part by giving money, buying indulgences or joining processions and prayers for the East.
Worked example: how a meeting became a legend
What happened when Francis met the sultan? The closest witness is Jacques de Vitry, a bishop in the crusader camp, who wrote soon afterward that Francis preached to the sultan for some days and that al-Kamil, moved, asked him to pray for him and had him escorted back safely. A Muslim source, an inscription on the tomb of a counselor of the sultan, may refer to the encounter, though its meaning is debated.
About forty years later, Bonaventure's official life of Francis added a dramatic scene: Francis offered to walk through fire with the sultan's scholars to prove which faith was true, and the scholars backed away. Later painters made that scene famous. Notice the pattern. The earliest account is modest and centers on courtesy. The later one, written to promote a saint, adds a contest and a victory. When a story improves with age, the improvements usually tell us more about the tellers than about the event. What remains well supported is striking enough: in the middle of a war, two men of rival faiths met, talked and parted in peace.
