Skip to main content

The Turkish state position

The Republic of Turkey does not deny that a great many Armenians died. Its position, which it presents in official statements and through historians who share it, runs as follows. In a desperate war on several fronts, the government faced Armenian revolutionaries who sided with an invading Russia, as at Van, and it relocated a population it considered a security threat. Turkey argues the deaths came from wartime relocation, disease and conflict, along with attacks by bandits and local feuds, in years when millions of Muslims also died of war, famine and epidemic. It holds that there was no central intent to destroy Armenians as a people, that the postwar courts-martial were held under foreign occupation and cannot be trusted, and that genocide is a legal term that only a competent court can apply. It refers to the events of 1915. In 2005 Turkey proposed a joint commission of Turkish and Armenian historians to study the archives, and in 2014 the prime minister, Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, offered condolences to the grandchildren of Armenians who died, describing a shared pain.

Each element contains something true. There was war, there were Armenian volunteers with Russia, and many Muslims suffered and died. Taking the position seriously means testing it against the evidence rather than dismissing it.

The scholarly consensus

Most historians who study the period, including Turkish scholars such as Taner Akçam, conclude that the events meet the definition of genocide. The definition used in international law, drawn from Lemkin's work, turns on intent to destroy a national, ethnic, racial or religious group, wholly or partly. Scholars point to evidence of that intent: deportation of women and children from places far from any front, the killing of men near their homes, the role of the Special Organization, the second wave of killing in the Syrian desert in 1916, orders limiting Armenians to a small share of the population in resettlement areas, and the seizure of property never meant to be returned. In 2008 a Turkish journalist published a notebook kept by Talat that put the Armenian population before and after deportation at figures implying the disappearance of most of it. Scholars weigh such numbers carefully, but the overall pattern is the basis for the consensus.

Speaking about it in Turkey

For decades the subject was nearly unspeakable in Turkey. Article 301 of the Turkish penal code, adopted in 2005, punished insulting the Turkish nation, and it was used against writers, including the novelist Orhan Pamuk, who had told a Swiss newspaper that a million Armenians had been killed; the charge was dropped. Hrant Dink, editor of the Armenian and Turkish weekly Agos, who argued for dialogue between Turks and Armenians, was shot dead outside his office in Istanbul in January 2007 by a young nationalist. Tens of thousands of people marched at his funeral carrying signs declaring that they too were Hrant Dink and that they too were Armenian. In 2004 the lawyer Fethiye Çetin published a memoir revealing that her grandmother was an Armenian survivor, raised as a Muslim after 1915. It helped many Turks discover hidden Armenian ancestors in their own families.

Recognition abroad

Uruguay is often cited as the first state to recognize the genocide, in 1965. The European Parliament followed in 1987, France passed a law in 2001, and in 2015 Pope Francis used the word genocide for the events at a Mass in Rome, prompting Turkey to recall its ambassador to the Vatican. In 2016 the German Bundestag recognized the genocide and acknowledged German complicity, since Germany had been the Ottoman ally. Both houses of the United States Congress passed resolutions in 2019, and the president used the word in 2021. More than thirty countries now recognize it. Turkey treats these steps as political judgments, and recognition debates are often tangled with alliances, trade and diaspora politics, which is a reason to judge the history on its evidence rather than on any vote.

Memory

Armenians call the events Medz Yeghern, the Great Catastrophe, and mark April 24 each year. In 1965, on the fiftieth anniversary, crowds marched in Soviet Yerevan, and two years later the Tsitsernakaberd memorial opened on a hill in Yerevan, with an eternal flame under a ring of leaning stone slabs. A worldwide diaspora, from Beirut to Los Angeles, grew from the survivors and orphans. Since 2010 small public commemorations have been held in Istanbul as well.

Worked example: weighing intent

Suppose a reader asks: how can anyone know what officials intended a century ago? Begin with what the two accounts share: war, deportation, and very large Armenian losses. Then ask which facts each account explains. Relocation for security explains moving people near the Russian front. It does not explain deporting Armenians from western towns hundreds of miles away, killing men before the columns left, letting irregulars attack the marches, or massacring survivors in the desert a year later. An intent to destroy explains all of these.

Next, look for evidence that does not depend on any single source: German reports, American cables, Ottoman court records, survivor testimony and the near disappearance of Armenians from eastern Anatolia. When independent sources converge, the conclusion is strong. Finally, keep two things apart. Accepting the evidence about 1915 is a judgment about a government and a party in wartime, not about Turks as a people, and many Turks have led the way in facing it. Honest memory honors the dead and leaves room for neighbors to live together.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What does the Turkish state argue caused the Armenian deaths?
2. What did Turkey propose in 2005?
3. What did Article 301 of the Turkish penal code punish?
4. Who was Hrant Dink?
5. What did Fethiye Çetin's memoir of 2004 reveal?
6. Which state is often cited as the first to recognize the genocide, in 1965?
7. What did the German Bundestag acknowledge in 2016?
8. What opened on a hill in Yerevan in 1967?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia