After the Second World War, modern architecture stopped being a rebellion and became the establishment. Governments facing bombed cities, booming populations and slum housing turned to its promise of speed, hygiene and order. The results include some of the century's finest buildings and some of its most bitter disappointments, and the argument over which is which continues.
The functional city
Modernist architects had organized themselves in an international congress known as CIAM, founded in 1928. Its best known statement, drawn from a 1933 meeting and later published as the Athens Charter, laid out a vision of the city. The Athens Charter proposed dividing the city into separate zones for dwelling, work, recreation and traffic. Towers would stand in open parkland, separated by fast roads. Le Corbusier went further in his plans for whole cities, and he finally built one, Chandigarh, the new capital of the Indian Punjab, in the 1950s.
Raw concrete
Many postwar public buildings used concrete left raw, showing the marks of the wooden forms into which it was poured. The name Brutalism comes from the French béton brut, meaning raw concrete, not from the word brutal, though critics enjoyed the pun. Its defenders saw honesty and strength: a style for universities, libraries, theaters and council housing that did not pretend to be anything else. Its critics saw gray, stained walls that turned cold and forbidding in wet climates and made public institutions look like fortresses.
The critics
Objections came from several directions. Urbanists such as Jane Jacobs attacked the functional city for killing the mixed, crowded streets where neighbors know one another. Architects attacked it from inside. In his 1966 book Complexity and Contradiction in Architecture, Robert Venturi defended richness, ambiguity and historical reference against modernist purity, and he turned a famous modernist slogan about simplicity on its head by suggesting that too little can simply be dull. His work helped open the way to postmodern architecture, with its playful borrowings from the past.
Others asked whose knowledge counted. The Egyptian architect Hassan Fathy revived mud brick building and Nubian vaulting to make low-cost housing for the rural poor, arguing that imported concrete was costly, hot and alien to the people meant to live in it. He insisted that the people who would use a building should take part in shaping it. His most famous project, the village of New Gourna near Luxor in the 1940s, struggled in practice, partly because the villagers, who were being moved from their old homes, did not want to go.
A later answer tried to keep the gains of modernism while restoring a sense of place. Critical regionalism is an approach that uses modern methods while responding to local climate, light, materials and culture. The term was coined by Alexander Tzonis and Liane Lefaivre, and it was popularized by the historian Kenneth Frampton in the early 1980s.
Weighing the record
A fair judgment has to hold two facts together. Modernist housing gave millions of families their first indoor toilets, hot water and sunlit rooms, and many estates and towers remain well loved, especially where they were maintained, mixed with shops and services, and well connected. Others failed, often because of underfunding, poor upkeep, segregation and isolation rather than design alone. Most historians now treat design as one cause among several. The deepest criticism of modernist planning was that it imposed a single rational scheme from above and gave too little voice to the people who would live in it.
Worked example: Brasília
In 1956 Brazil's president Juscelino Kubitschek set out to move the capital from coastal Rio de Janeiro to the empty interior. The urbanist Lúcio Costa won the competition for the city plan, and the architect Oscar Niemeyer designed its major buildings. The city was inaugurated in April 1960, after barely four years of construction. From the air the plan resembles an airplane or a bird, with ministries along a monumental axis and housing in large superblocks along curving wings.
Read it with both the defenders and the critics in mind. Niemeyer's sweeping concrete curves, such as the Cathedral and the National Congress, are among the most admired buildings of the century, and the superblocks gave residents green space, schools and shops close by. Yet the city was planned for cars, with long distances and few lively streets, and the planned core had little room for the tens of thousands of workers who built it. Most of them settled in satellite towns beyond the plan, and today the great majority of the region's people live outside the original design. Brasília shows what a confident plan can achieve, and how easily a plan for a whole nation can leave out the people who made it.
