Skip to main content

In 1922 the physicist and philosopher Moritz Schlick took up a chair at the University of Vienna. Within a few years a group gathered around him on Thursday evenings: the logician Rudolf Carnap, the economist and social reformer Otto Neurath, the mathematicians Hans Hahn and Olga Hahn-Neurath, the physicist Philipp Frank, and younger members such as Herbert Feigl, Friedrich Waismann and Rose Rand. The Vienna Circle became the most self-consciously modern philosophical movement of its time, with sister groups in Berlin, Prague, Warsaw and beyond.

A manifesto

In 1929 Carnap, Hahn and Neurath published a pamphlet titled The Scientific Conception of the World. It announced a program. Philosophy should not produce its own body of doctrine; it should clarify the statements of science by logical analysis. All genuine knowledge comes from experience and logic. The sciences should be unified in a single language, so that physics, biology, psychology and sociology could speak to one another. Traditional metaphysics, which claimed knowledge beyond any possible experience, should be cleared away.

The manifesto was not only academic. It tied philosophy to Enlightenment ideals and social reform. Vienna in the 1920s was governed by Social Democrats who built tens of thousands of public apartments and ran adult education programs, and many Circle members saw their work as part of that project. They founded a society for popular lectures and believed that clear, scientific thinking would help ordinary people resist superstition, nationalism and manipulation.

Building the world from experience

Carnap's book The Logical Structure of the World (1928) tried to show how this might work. It aimed to construct the concepts of science step by step from elementary experiences, using only logic, much as Principia Mathematica had built mathematics from logical starting points. Carnap later saw that the construction could not be completed, but its ambition shaped decades of work.

Carnap against Heidegger

In a 1932 essay on overcoming metaphysics through the logical analysis of language, Carnap chose as his example a sentence from a 1929 lecture by the German philosopher Martin Heidegger, roughly: "the nothing itself nothings." Carnap argued that the sentence treats "nothing" as if it named a thing. In ordinary speech, "nothing is outside" means that there is no thing that is outside, just as Russell had analyzed "nobody." Heidegger's sentence turns this quantifier into a subject that does something, and so says nothing at all.

Carnap did not think metaphysicians were simply fools. He suggested that metaphysics expresses an attitude toward life, which art and music express better. Metaphysicians, he wrote in substance, are like musicians without musical ability: they have something to express, but they put it into the form of theory, where it does not belong. Defenders of Heidegger replied that Carnap had read a meditation on human finitude as if it were a botched sentence of physics.

Tolerance in logic

Carnap's later work softened the Circle's dogmatism. In The Logical Syntax of Language (1934) he proposed a principle of tolerance: anyone may build their own logical language, provided they state its rules clearly. There is no single correct logic waiting to be discovered; there are frameworks, to be judged by how useful they are.

Pictures for the public

Neurath carried the program into the streets. At Vienna's Social and Economic Museum he and his collaborators, Marie Reidemeister and the designer Gerd Arntz, developed Isotype, a picture language for presenting social statistics to the public. Its charts used simple, standard pictograms: a small figure for a thousand people, a small ship for a quantity of tonnage. The key rule was to show larger quantities with more symbols, not bigger symbols.

Scattered

The Circle did not survive the politics of the 1930s. Austria's democracy collapsed in 1934, Schlick was murdered in 1936, and after Germany annexed Austria in 1938 nearly every member had fled. Carnap went to Chicago and later Los Angeles, Neurath to the Netherlands and then England, where he died in 1945. In exile the movement, now usually called logical empiricism, transformed American philosophy of science.

Worked example: drawing the housing crisis

A city wants to show voters that the number of families on its housing waiting list has doubled in ten years, from 5,000 to 10,000. One designer draws a single house icon for each year and makes the second house twice as tall. A second designer, following Isotype, draws five identical houses for the first year and ten for the second, each house standing for a thousand families.

The first chart misleads. A house twice as tall is also twice as wide, so it covers four times the area, and viewers see a fourfold rise. The second chart can be read at a glance, even by someone who struggles with numbers, and it cannot be quietly exaggerated. Neurath believed that citizens have a right to understand the facts that govern their lives, and that presenting those facts honestly is a democratic duty. His rule of more symbols, not bigger ones, puts that belief into practice.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What was the title of the Vienna Circle's 1929 manifesto?
2. What did the manifesto tie philosophy to, beyond academic work?
3. What did Carnap's The Logical Structure of the World (1928) aim to do?
4. What was Carnap's charge against Heidegger's sentence about "the nothing"?
5. What did Carnap say metaphysics really expresses?
6. What does Carnap's principle of tolerance allow?
7. What was Isotype?
8. What was Isotype's key rule for showing quantities?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia