A system of camps
The Soviet state used camps from its first years. In 1923 a camp opened in an old monastery on the Solovetsky Islands in the White Sea, and it became a laboratory for using prisoners as workers. In 1930 the secret police created a central office to run the growing network, the Main Administration of Camps, known by its Russian acronym, GULAG. The word came to stand for the whole system: corrective labor camps, smaller labor colonies, prisons and the special settlements where deported peasants and later whole nations lived under guard.
The camps held ordinary criminals as well as political prisoners, and the line between them was blurred, since many "crimes" were things like lateness at work, petty theft from a farm or a careless joke. Historians estimate that about 18 million people passed through the camps and colonies between 1930 and 1953, and millions more were deported to special settlements. Camp records list about 1.6 million deaths, but historians think the true figure is higher because dying prisoners were often released shortly before death, so that they would not count against the camp's statistics.
Labor and the economy
The Gulag was also an economic empire. Prisoners felled timber, dug canals, laid railways and mined coal and metals in places free workers would not go. The first great showpiece was the White Sea to Baltic Canal, built in about twenty months between 1931 and 1933, largely by hand, with wheelbarrows, picks and wooden scaffolding. Thousands died. Yet it was celebrated in a book written by a team of famous writers, edited by Maxim Gorky, which praised the camp as a place where criminals were reforged into good Soviet citizens.
In the far northeast, the trust known as Dalstroi ran camps in the Kolyma region, reached by ship through the port of Magadan. There prisoners mined gold, above all, in a climate where winter temperatures can fall below minus fifty degrees. Kolyma became a byword for the deadliest part of the system.
From Kirov to the Terror
On 1 December 1934 Sergei Kirov, the party chief in Leningrad, was shot dead in his headquarters. Historians still debate whether Stalin had a hand in the killing. What is certain is how it was used. That same day a decree sped up terrorism cases, with no defense lawyers and no appeal, and death sentences carried out at once.
A series of public show trials in Moscow followed. In 1936 Zinoviev and Kamenev, once Lenin's close comrades, confessed to fantastic plots and were shot. In 1937 and 1938 other leading Bolsheviks, including Bukharin, followed them. In June 1937 Marshal Mikhail Tukhachevsky and other senior commanders were tried in secret and executed, and the purge of the officer corps that followed left the army badly weakened. The secret police chief Nikolai Yezhov ran the worst phase, and the period is sometimes named after him. He was himself arrested in 1939 and shot in 1940.
The terror reached far beyond the elite. Order No. 00447 of 30 July 1937 launched a mass operation against "former kulaks", criminals and other "anti-Soviet elements". It set quotas of arrests and executions for each region, and cases were decided by three-person boards called troikas, usually in minutes and without the accused present. So-called national operations targeted Poles, Germans, Latvians and other groups seen as potential enemies; the Polish operation alone killed more than 100,000 people.
Who was responsible?
Robert Conquest's history of the Great Terror, published in 1968, placed responsibility squarely on Stalin. Later historians such as J. Arch Getty stressed chaos, rivalries and pressure from below. The archives opened after 1991 settled much of the argument. They show that Stalin personally approved lists of people to be shot, hundreds of lists with tens of thousands of names, and that Moscow set and raised the quotas. Local officials often pushed for more, but they were responding to signals from the center. Trotsky, the regime's most famous critic abroad, was hunted down in Mexico and killed by a Soviet agent with an ice axe in August 1940.
Worked example: a quota for death
Read Order No. 00447 as a document. It begins with a list of categories of people, moves to a table of numbers by region and ends with instructions on paperwork. The first category, to be shot, was set at about 76,000 people across the country; the second, to be sent to camps, at about 186,500. Regional police chiefs soon asked for higher limits, and Moscow usually granted them. By the time the operation ended in November 1938, more than 350,000 people had been shot under this order alone.
What does the form of the document tell us? It treats human beings as units to be counted and allocated, like tons of steel in a plan. A police chief could meet his quota by arresting people whose names appeared in old files, or simply anyone who had once been a kulak, a priest or a trader. Guilt was not discovered; it was assigned. That is the opposite of the principle that each person must be judged individually, on evidence, by a court that can acquit. When the society Memorial began collecting victims' names in the late 1980s, it was answering the order in kind: replacing numbers with persons, one name at a time.
