Realism promised audiences a window onto life. By the early twentieth century many artists thought the window had become a trap: it left spectators passive, absorbed in illusion while history happened outside. A wave of experiments set out to smash the glass.
Against illusion
In revolutionary Russia the director Vsevolod Meyerhold, once an actor with Stanislavski, rejected psychological realism. Meyerhold's biomechanics trained actors in precise, athletic movement, drawing on circus, commedia and studies of efficient factory labor, and his productions used bare scaffolds and ramps instead of painted rooms. His career ended in Stalin's terror: he was arrested in 1939 and shot in 1940. In France, Antonin Artaud called for a theatre of cruelty. Artaud's theatre of cruelty meant an assault on the senses, not literal sadism, a theatre of sound, light, gesture and shock that would reach audiences beneath the level of words. He was inspired partly by Balinese dancers he saw at the Paris Colonial Exhibition of 1931.
Brecht's epic theatre
The most influential of these rebels was the German playwright and director Bertolt Brecht. He wanted audiences to think, not merely to feel. Brecht's epic theatre aimed to make spectators judge the social causes of events instead of losing themselves in the story. Ordinary theatre, he believed, hypnotized its public, inviting them to share a hero's feelings and accept the world as fixed, when in fact that world was made by human choices and could be changed.
His central technique is usually translated as the alienation or estrangement effect. The estrangement effect makes the familiar look strange so that audiences start to question it. Brecht used many means: placards or projections announcing what a scene would show, songs that broke off the action to comment on it, bright even lighting, visible stage machinery, and actors who presented their characters as if quoting them. He also developed the idea of gestus, a physical attitude that reveals a character's social relationships, such as the way a servant sets down a plate before a master. The Threepenny Opera, written with the composer Kurt Weill in 1928, satirized capitalism through a story of beggars and thieves, and its songs became hits across Weimar Germany.
Brecht found support for his theory in an unexpected place. In 1935 he saw the great Chinese performer Mei Lanfang give a demonstration in Moscow. Mei was a master of jingju, often called Peking opera, which blends song, speech, mime and acrobatics. Mei Lanfang was famous for playing dan roles, the female characters of jingju, through a precise and highly stylized art. Brecht was struck that a performer could display an emotion while also visibly showing how it was made, and he wrote an essay holding up Chinese acting as an example of estrangement. Specialists in Chinese theatre have since argued that he misread jingju, which pursues its own kind of beauty rather than critical distance.
Brecht fled Germany in 1933, wrote his major plays in exile, and later returned to East Berlin, where his company, the Berliner Ensemble, became famous. In 1947, while living in California, he was questioned by a congressional committee investigating communism, and he left the United States the next day. Critics point to a paradox in his work: audiences often wept for his characters anyway, as if feeling and thinking could not be pulled apart after all.
The Theatre of the Absurd
After the Second World War, another group of writers abandoned not only realism but ordinary logic. The critic Martin Esslin coined the phrase Theatre of the Absurd in 1961 for plays that portrayed human existence as lacking any clear purpose, through circular dialogue, broken reasoning and situations left unexplained. Eugène Ionesco's The Bald Soprano (1950) dissolves into nonsense borrowed from a language textbook. The movement drew on the idea, made famous by Albert Camus, that life is absurd because people search for meaning in a universe that offers none. Unlike Brecht, absurdist playwrights generally showed the human condition rather than arguing for a political program. Many of these writers disliked the label, and Samuel Beckett refused to explain his plays at all.
Worked example: Godot in a prison yard
Beckett's Waiting for Godot opened in Paris in 1953. Two tramps, Vladimir and Estragon, wait by a bare tree for someone called Godot, who never comes. Early audiences in London and Miami were often baffled, and some walked out. On 19 November 1957 a San Francisco company performed it for about fourteen hundred inmates of San Quentin prison. The actors feared jeers. Instead the men watched closely and afterward said they understood it perfectly: they knew what it was to wait for something that might never arrive. One inmate, Rick Cluchey, later started a drama group inside the prison and, after his release, worked with Beckett himself. The episode answers a common objection, that absurdist theatre is a puzzle for intellectuals. For people whose own lives felt suspended, the play was not abstract at all.
