Skip to main content

Nineteenth century audiences loved melodrama: clear villains, wronged heroines, rescues at the last second and music cueing every emotion. Stage technology made spectacle ever grander, with gas lighting, collapsing bridges and sinking ships. Against all this, a group of writers and directors in the late nineteenth century demanded something harder: plays that showed ordinary life as it really was.

The real world on stage

Realism aimed to show everyday life and recognizable social problems through believable characters, dialogue and settings. A key tool was the box set, a room built with three solid walls, often a ceiling, and real doors and furniture. The audience looked in as if through an invisible fourth wall. The idea is older than the movement: in 1758 the French writer Denis Diderot advised playwrights and actors to imagine a great wall across the front of the stage and to behave as if no one were watching. Darkening the auditorium during performances, which became common in the late nineteenth century, helped spectators forget themselves and peer into the lit room.

Naturalism pushed further. The French novelist Émile Zola argued that theatre should study human beings the way a scientist studies nature. Naturalism treated character as the product of heredity and environment, and its stages could be startlingly literal: at André Antoine's Théâtre Libre in Paris, founded in 1887, a play about butchers was performed with real carcasses of meat hanging on stage.

Ibsen and Chekhov

The Norwegian Henrik Ibsen became realism's most explosive writer. He took the tightly plotted machinery of popular drama and filled it with questions about marriage, money, inheritance and public lies. Ghosts, which touches on inherited syphilis, so shocked theatre managers that European theatres refused it, and its world premiere was given in Chicago in 1882, in the original language, for Scandinavian immigrants.

The Russian Anton Chekhov wrote a quieter realism. In his plays people talk about the weather while their lives slip away, and the big events often happen offstage. Chekhov's drama puts much of its meaning beneath the dialogue, in what characters leave unsaid, a layer actors call subtext. His Seagull failed badly at its first performance in St Petersburg in 1896, and Chekhov vowed to give up writing plays. Two years later a new company turned it into a triumph.

Stanislavski's system

That company was the Moscow Art Theatre, founded in 1898 by Konstantin Stanislavski and Vladimir Nemirovich-Danchenko after a famous restaurant conversation said to have lasted eighteen hours. Realistic plays needed realistic acting, and Stanislavski spent the rest of his life trying to describe how a performer could live truthfully inside invented circumstances, night after night. His teachings became known as the system.

Several of its tools are taught almost everywhere. The given circumstances are the facts of the character's situation supplied by the play: who, where, when and what has just happened. The "magic if" asks actors what they would do if these circumstances were real, turning imagination into action. Each scene is broken into units, and an objective is what the character wants to achieve at a given moment, phrased as a verb the actor can play: to win her trust, to get out of the room. The objectives add up to a through line and a super-objective that drives the whole role. Early on Stanislavski also explored emotion memory, the recall of feelings from one's own life, but later in his career Stanislavski stressed physical actions as the path to truthful emotion, arguing that feelings cannot be forced and will follow from clear, purposeful action.

His ideas reached the United States through émigré teachers and the Group Theatre of the 1930s, where they split. Lee Strasberg's Method emphasized affective memory, drawing on the actor's own past emotions. Stella Adler, who worked with Stanislavski in Paris in 1934, came back insisting that imagination and the given circumstances mattered more than private recall. Critics of the Method argue that digging into personal pain can harm actors and blur the line between actor and role; defenders point to the vivid, unguarded performances it produced on stage and film.

Worked example: a door slams

Ibsen's A Doll's House premiered in Copenhagen in 1879. Nora Helmer, a cheerful wife who once secretly forged a signature to save her husband's life, discovers that he values his reputation more than her. In the last scene she tells him she must educate herself and walks out, leaving husband and children behind. The sound of the door closing shocked audiences across Europe. A leading German actress refused to play that ending, and Ibsen, to stop someone else from rewriting it, supplied an alternative in which Nora sees her sleeping children and stays. He called the change a barbaric outrage. An actor using Stanislavski's tools today would begin with the given circumstances: Christmas, secret debt, a blackmailer's letter in the box. Her objective in the final scene might be "to make him finally hear me", which plays very differently from "to punish him". The choice of one verb changes the whole ending.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did Diderot advise playwrights and actors in 1758?
2. How did naturalism view character?
3. Where does much of the meaning in Chekhov's plays lie?
4. In Stanislavski's system, what are the given circumstances?
5. What does the "magic if" ask actors?
6. What is an objective in Stanislavski's system?
7. What did Stanislavski stress later in his career?
8. What did Lee Strasberg's Method emphasize?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia