A disaster that kills a third or more of the population leaves behind fields, houses and tools but far fewer hands to use them. Before 1348, much of Europe had too many people for its land: wages were low, rents high and the poor close to hunger. Within a few years that balance flipped, and the struggle over what would follow shaped the late Middle Ages.
Fewer hands, higher wages
Survivors who worked for wages found that employers competed for them. Harvest workers, carpenters and plowmen asked for more and often got it. Tenants found land easier to get and lords readier to bargain. Over the following century the gains added up. English laborers' real wages roughly doubled between the early fourteenth and the mid fifteenth century, by most estimates. Ordinary people ate more meat and drank more ale, and the nineteenth-century economist James Thorold Rogers, who collected centuries of wage and price records, called the fifteenth century a golden age of the English laborer.
Laws against change
The ruling classes did not welcome this. In England, laws of 1349 and 1351 tried to hold wages at old levels and force able people to work. Lords tried to enforce old labor services. Governments also tried to keep people in their place in other ways. England's sumptuary law of 1363 regulated clothing and food by social rank, so that a servant could not dress like a merchant or a merchant like a knight. It proved impossible to enforce and was repealed the next year, though similar laws followed. Across Europe, similar wage laws met the same problem: when labor was scarce, employers broke the rules themselves to hire the workers they needed.
Serfdom fades in the west, hardens in the east
In England and much of western Europe, serfdom slowly withered. Lords who could not hold tenants by force turned labor services into money rents, leased out their own farms and let unfree status lapse. By 1500 serfdom had largely disappeared in England. East of the Elbe river the story ran the other way. In Poland, Prussia, Bohemia and later Russia, nobles used their political power to tie peasants more tightly to the land, partly to grow grain for western markets. The "second serfdom" was a tightening of serfdom east of the Elbe from the fifteenth century on. The same shock produced opposite results, depending on who held power. Historians still argue whether population, class struggle or markets did most to decide the outcome.
Land use changed too. Many English landlords, short of workers, turned grain fields into sheep pasture, since sheep needed few hands and wool sold well. Some villages shrank and were abandoned over the following century and a half. Archaeologists can still trace their outlines in fields as grassy mounds where houses stood and shallow hollows where streets ran. Most such villages died slowly, from falling numbers, the pull of better land elsewhere and lords who preferred sheep to tenants, rather than being emptied in a single season of plague.
Revolts
Higher expectations, heavy war taxes and resentment of old burdens led to risings. In France in 1358 peasants rose against nobles in the Jacquerie. In Florence in 1378 came the revolt of the Ciompi: wool workers in Florence rose in the Ciompi revolt, won the right to form their own guilds and briefly shared in the city's government before being crushed. In England in 1381, rebels from Essex and Kent marched on London and demanded an end to serfdom. All these risings were defeated, yet over time much of what the English rebels had asked for came anyway.
Winners and losers
Did women gain? The historian Jeremy Goldberg argued that women in York found more paid work after the plague, and that some married later because they could support themselves. Others doubt the gains were large or lasting. Comparison also shows that recovery was not automatic. Stuart Borsch argued that Egypt recovered more slowly because its elite kept rents high as irrigation decayed. Egypt's Mamluk rulers held the land collectively and kept squeezing peasants, and the canals that fed farming needed labor that was no longer there. England's lords, competing against one another for tenants, had to give way.
Worked example: a lord's choices in 1352
Picture a lord whose manor had sixty tenant households before the plague and now has thirty-five. Twelve holdings stand empty. His reeve reports that hired laborers demand twice the old wage, and two tenants have slipped away to a neighboring manor where the lord asks less.
The lord has four options. He can try to enforce the wage law and chase his runaways through the courts, which is costly and breeds anger. He can lower rents and drop labor services to attract new tenants. He can lease his own farm for a fixed rent and stop farming directly. Or he can put the empty land under sheep. Across England, lords tried all four, often in that order. The first failed most often. The others, adopted one manor at a time, added up over generations to the end of English serfdom. The example shows how large historical changes can come from many small, local decisions under pressure.
