Skip to main content

The Black Death killed Christians, Muslims and Jews alike. Yet in much of western and central Europe, Christian neighbors turned on Jewish communities and murdered thousands of people for a crime that never happened. These killings were among the worst violence against Jews in Europe before modern times, and they show how fear, old hatred and self-interest can combine in a crisis.

An old fear, a ready target

Jews in medieval Christian Europe lived under the protection of kings, bishops and city councils, who taxed them heavily and could withdraw that protection at will. England had expelled its Jews in 1290 and France had expelled them repeatedly. Stories that Jews murdered Christian children or abused the communion bread had already led to massacres. The idea of secret poisoning had a recent model too. In 1321, in France, rumor spread of a plot by lepers to poison wells, said to have been paid for by Jews and a Muslim king. Lepers were burned and Jews were attacked and later expelled.

Confessions under torture

When plague arrived in 1348, the poisoning charge was turned on Jews. The first massacres came in southern France and Spain in the spring and summer, where mobs blamed Jews for the deaths. In Catalonia, rioters attacked the Jewish quarters of Barcelona and Tàrrega. At Tàrrega in 2007, archaeologists found mass graves of Jews killed in 1348, many bearing wounds from blades.

The charge then gained a false appearance of proof. In September 1348, officials of the count of Savoy tortured Jewish prisoners until they confessed. At Chillon, on Lake Geneva, Jews were tortured into confessing to poisoning wells. A surgeon named Balavigny "confessed" that a rabbi had given him poison in a small packet to throw into wells. Copies of these forced confessions were sent from town to town, and city councils treated them as evidence.

From the Rhine to the Baltic

The killings spread through Switzerland and the German lands in the winter of 1348 and through 1349. In Basel in January 1349, the town's Jews were locked inside a wooden building on an island in the Rhine and burned. In Erfurt, in March, the community was destroyed; the Erfurt Treasure is a hoard of valuables a Jewish family hid in 1349, found inside a wall in 1998, including coins, jewelry and a gold wedding ring. In Mainz, in August, the Jews of Mainz resisted their attackers, and many died in the fires that followed. Frankfurt, Cologne and dozens of smaller towns saw similar killings. Hundreds of Jewish communities were destroyed or scattered.

Not simply panic

It is tempting to explain all this as terror in the face of death. The timing argues against it. Many attacks came before the plague arrived in a town, sometimes months before, so they were not the acts of people maddened by dying neighbors. Political struggles mattered. In February 1349 Strasbourg's guilds removed a council that had protected the Jews, and the new council allowed the killing. So did money. Jews were moneylenders in many towns, because Christian law barred Christians from charging interest, and nobles, clergy and townspeople owed them large sums. Debts owed to murdered Jews were cancelled or seized by lords and towns, and their property was divided.

Not every authority joined in. Pope Clement VI issued bulls in 1348 forbidding the killings, and some rulers and councils tried to protect their Jews, though often to keep a valuable source of taxes. Their efforts were weak against crowds and councils that wanted the killings to happen.

Worked example: Strasbourg, February 1349

The chronicle of Jacob Twinger of Königshofen, written a generation later from earlier accounts, tells the story. The city's leaders, headed by a magistrate named Peter Swarber, argued that the Jews were innocent and refused to act against them. The craft guilds, angry with the ruling families for other reasons as well, marched under arms and deposed the council. The new rulers had the Jews arrested and burned on 14 February 1349 in their own cemetery. Twinger puts the dead at around two thousand; modern historians think the true figure was lower, though still in the hundreds at least. Those who agreed to be baptized were spared. The debts owed to the Jews were cancelled and their money was shared among the craftsmen.

What does a historian take from this account? First, the plague had not yet reached Strasbourg, which shows that the killing was a choice, not a frenzy of grief. Second, the conflict over the Jews was bound up with a struggle for power inside the city. Third, Twinger himself drew the moral that their wealth, not any poison, was the cause of their deaths. A good reading keeps all three in view and does not reduce the event to a single cause. It also remembers the victims as people with names, families and a long history in the town, not as an abstraction. The lesson reaches beyond the Middle Ages: when a society looks for someone to blame, the most vulnerable neighbors are at greatest risk, and the people who stand to gain often decide who will be blamed.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What alleged plot of 1321 foreshadowed the plague-era accusations?
2. Where were Jews tortured into confessing in September 1348?
3. What did archaeologists find at Tàrrega in 2007?
4. What did Strasbourg's guilds do in February 1349?
5. Why do historians doubt that plague panic alone explains the killings?
6. What happened to debts owed to murdered Jews?
7. What is the Erfurt Treasure?
8. What happened to the Jews of Mainz in August 1349?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia