People facing the great mortality wanted to know why it had come and what they could do. They answered with the best ideas they had: the medicine of the ancient Greeks, the astronomy of the universities and the teachings of their faiths. Their explanations were wrong about the cause, but they were not foolish, and some observations made at the bedside were sharp.
Bad air and the stars
In October 1348 the king of France asked the medical faculty of the University of Paris for an explanation. The Paris medical faculty blamed a conjunction of Saturn, Jupiter and Mars in 1345, which it said had corrupted the air. The near cause, the doctors agreed, was poisoned air rising from swamps, rotting bodies or vapors released by earthquakes. This was miasma theory: the idea that disease comes from corrupted air. It came from Greek medicine and dominated European and Middle Eastern thought for centuries.
Miasma theory had practical results. Doctors told people to burn fragrant woods and herbs, carry sweet-smelling posies, avoid southern winds and keep windows facing north. Some of this advice was useless. Some, such as cleaning streets and burying the dead quickly, did a little good for the wrong reasons.
Physicians at the bedside
Guy de Chauliac, physician to Pope Clement VI at Avignon, stayed in the city through the epidemic and caught the disease himself, surviving to describe it years later. Chauliac described a deadly lung form first, then a form with swellings. In the first two months, he wrote, the sick had a continuous fever and spat blood and died within three days; later, the sick developed swellings in the armpits and groin and died within five. Modern readers recognize pneumonic and bubonic plague. The Italian physician Gentile da Foligno wrote several advice treatises in 1348 and died of the plague that June, reportedly after treating the sick.
Contagion argued from experience
In Muslim Spain, two physicians went further. Ibn Khatima of Almeria and Ibn al-Khatib of Granada both argued that the disease passed from person to person. Ibn al-Khatib argued for contagion from experience and observed cases: people who touched the sick or their clothes fell ill, while some who shut themselves away survived. He noted a man in the Moroccan port of Salé who had sealed his household away from the town and kept it healthy. This mattered because some religious scholars rejected contagion, on the ground that only God sends disease. Ibn al-Khatib answered that a reliable observation could not be set aside.
God's anger and the flagellants
Most Christians saw the plague as a punishment for sin. Churches held processions, people made vows and built chapels, and cities appealed to saints such as Sebastian, whose body was pierced by arrows, and later Roch, a pilgrim said to have caught plague and been fed by a dog. In the German lands in 1348 and 1349, bands of flagellants marched from town to town, whipping their own backs in public to win God's mercy. A flagellant's penance traditionally lasted thirty-three and a half days, one day for each year of Christ's life on earth. Crowds welcomed them at first, but the movement worried bishops, who could not control it, and in some towns flagellant visits came just before attacks on Jews. In October 1349 Pope Clement VI condemned the flagellants in a papal bull.
A different reading in the Islamic world
Muslim scholars drew on a different tradition. Sayings attributed to the Prophet taught that believers should neither enter a land struck by plague nor flee from it. Many Muslim scholars taught that death by plague was a martyrdom and a mercy for believers. This did not mean passive acceptance: people prayed, fasted and tended the sick. The traveler Ibn Battuta was in Damascus in July 1348 and wrote that the whole city fasted for three days and then walked out together to a mosque on the edge of town. Ibn Battuta saw Muslims, Jews and Christians praying together, each carrying their own holy book, to ask God to lift the plague.
Worked example: weighing a plague tract's advice
Suppose a tract of 1348 gives four pieces of advice: flee early, go far and return late; burn juniper and rosemary in the house; avoid baths, which open the pores to bad air; and eat lightly, avoiding fruit and fish. How would each have worked?
Flight was the most effective, because it reduced contact with infected people, rats and fleas, though fleeing townspeople also carried the disease into the countryside, and only the well off could afford it. Burning herbs may have driven off some fleas, by accident. Avoiding baths did no good and may have made people dirtier and more infested. The diet advice did nothing at all. The lesson is not that medieval doctors were stupid, but that advice built on a wrong theory can still contain useful parts, found by experience and kept for the wrong reasons.
