Skip to main content

News of the surrender reached London in the late summer of 1839. Lord Palmerston decided to send a fleet, and the government did so without asking Parliament for a formal declaration of war. Its opponents forced a debate anyway.

Debate in London

In April 1840 the Conservative opposition moved a motion censuring the government's handling of China. Supporters of the expedition talked of insulted honor, unpaid debts and the right to trade. Critics, among them the young William Gladstone, called it a war fought to protect a shameful traffic. The government survived the censure motion by nine votes, 271 to 262. Notably, the motion attacked the government's competence rather than the opium trade itself, which let many members criticize ministers without condemning the trade.

The expedition

A force of warships, transports and troops, many of them Indian soldiers, arrived off Canton in June 1840, soon commanded by Rear Admiral George Elliot, a cousin of Charles. It blockaded the river and sailed north. In July 1840 British forces seized Zhoushan, which they called Chusan, an island off the coast south of Shanghai, and its town of Dinghai. Many British soldiers there later died of disease, a reminder that sickness killed more men on the British side than combat did.

The fleet then reached the mouth of the river leading to Tianjin, uncomfortably close to Beijing. The alarmed emperor dismissed Lin Zexu, blaming him for the crisis, and sent the Manchu official Qishan to negotiate. Qishan persuaded the British to return south. In January 1841, after a British attack on forts near Canton, he and Charles Elliot agreed the Convention of Chuenpi: Hong Kong Island would go to Britain, an indemnity would be paid and trade would reopen.

Neither side accepted it. Both governments rejected the Convention of Chuenpi. The emperor thought Qishan had given away far too much, and Qishan was dismissed and sent to Beijing in chains, where he was sentenced to death, though the sentence was not carried out. Palmerston thought Elliot had won far too little, dismissing Hong Kong as a barren island with hardly a house on it, and replaced him with Sir Henry Pottinger.

Steam and guns

The Qing army was large but scattered across a vast empire, and its coastal forts had guns that were old and badly mounted. Banner and Green Standard troops fought bravely in many places, but they faced a navy built by the world's leading industrial power. The most striking new weapon was the Nemesis, an iron-hulled steamship of the East India Company. It could move against wind and current and drew so little water that it could work up rivers and creeks where sailing warships could not follow.

In May 1841 British forces stood ready to storm Canton, and local officials paid a ransom of six million dollars to spare the city. Just afterward came an episode the British remembered least and the Chinese remembered most. At Sanyuanli, local militia surrounded British-led troops caught in a heavy rainstorm that left many of their muskets unable to fire. Officials persuaded the militia to disperse, and the casualties were small. Yet in later Chinese memory Sanyuanli became a symbol of ordinary people resisting invaders when their rulers would not.

The Yangzi campaign

Pottinger, arriving in August 1841, took Xiamen, Ningbo and other coastal towns, then in 1842 moved up the Yangzi River. The decisive blow fell in July 1842 at Zhenjiang, where the Grand Canal, which carried tax grain to the north, crossed the Yangzi. Taking the city cut the Grand Canal route, though its Manchu garrison resisted fiercely, and many soldiers' families killed themselves rather than be captured. With British ships approaching Nanjing, the court gave way. The treaty was signed aboard the warship Cornwallis off Nanjing on 29 August 1842.

Lin Zexu, meanwhile, had been exiled to Ili in the far northwest. He served there with distinction and was later recalled to high office, but he never again directed policy toward the West.

Worked example: why did a small force win?

At its peak Britain had perhaps 20,000 soldiers and sailors in China, facing an empire of around 400 million people. How did it win? A historian weighing the causes might list four. First, technology: steamships, heavier cannon and better muskets gave a sharp edge in coastal fighting. Second, mobility: control of the sea let the British choose where to strike and concentrate force, while Qing troops had to march for weeks. Third, strategy: by seizing Zhenjiang, the British threatened the grain supply of the capital rather than trying to conquer territory. Fourth, information: officials at the front often sent misleading reports of victory to Beijing, so the emperor long misjudged the danger. No single factor explains the result. The careful conclusion is that a modest force used its advantages at the empire's most vulnerable points, while the court's own channels of information failed it.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. How did the censure motion over China end in April 1840?
2. Which island did British forces seize in July 1840?
3. What happened to the Convention of Chuenpi?
4. What happened to Qishan after the convention?
5. What was the Nemesis?
6. What happened at Sanyuanli in May 1841?
7. Why did the capture of Zhenjiang in 1842 matter so much?
8. Where was the Treaty of Nanjing signed?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia