Skip to main content

In 1657 Shah Jahan fell seriously ill, and his four adult sons prepared to fight for the throne. Mughal succession had no fixed rule, and the custom was brutal: princes who lost usually died. This war of succession, fought from 1657 to 1659, decided not only who would rule but what kind of empire it would be.

Two brothers

The eldest, Dara Shikoh, was his father's favorite and lived at court. He was a Sufi of the Qadiri order and a serious student of other religions. In a short book called the Confluence of the Two Oceans he argued that Sufism and Hindu Vedanta expressed the same truths in different words. His Sirr-i Akbar, the Great Secret, was a Persian translation of fifty Upanishads, made with the help of Hindu pandits. Through a later Latin version, it introduced the Upanishads to European philosophers.

His brother Aurangzeb had spent years governing the Deccan and leading armies. He was disciplined, austere and a strict Sunni, and he presented himself as the defender of orthodoxy against a brother he called an unbeliever. Aurangzeb defeated Dara at Samugarh, near Agra, in 1658. He then outfought his other brothers, confined his father and took the title Alamgir, "World Conqueror". In 1659 Dara, betrayed and captured, was paraded through Delhi and executed after scholars judged him guilty of apostasy.

The long reign

Aurangzeb ruled for almost fifty years. He sponsored a great collection of legal opinions. The Fatawa-i Alamgiri was a compilation of Hanafi Islamic law, drawn up by hundreds of scholars as a guide for judges. He cut back court ceremony, stopped the morning appearance at the palace window and withdrew patronage from court musicians, though music never stopped among the nobility. He ordered the destruction of some major temples, including in Varanasi and Mathura, while confirming land grants to many others. He was also a tireless administrator who read petitions himself and, it is said, copied the Quran by hand and sold the copies to meet his own needs.

His reputation has always divided historians. The great Bengali historian Jadunath Sarkar, writing in the early twentieth century, portrayed a zealot whose bigotry broke the empire. Later historians have stressed political motives: temples linked to rebels were targeted, and loyal temples protected. The debate continues in public life as well as in scholarship.

The Maratha challenge

In the hills of the western Deccan a new power was rising. Shivaji Bhonsle, son of a commander in the service of Bijapur, built a state from hill forts and fast light cavalry. In 1659 he killed Bijapur's general Afzal Khan at a parley, and in 1664 he sacked Surat. Forced to terms in 1665, he went to Aurangzeb's court. At Agra in 1666 Shivaji was held under guard and then escaped, reputedly hidden in baskets of sweets, and returned home to build a kingdom.

In 1681 Aurangzeb moved south with his court and army, and he spent the last twenty six years of his life there. In 1686 and 1687 he conquered the sultanates of Bijapur and Golconda, and in 1689 Shivaji's son Sambhaji was captured and executed. But the Marathas kept fighting under new leaders, including the regent Tarabai, raiding Mughal lands and avoiding pitched battle. Aurangzeb took fort after fort and lost many of them again.

Sikhs and Rajputs

Resistance also hardened in the north. A disputed succession in the Rajput kingdom of Marwar in 1679 led to a long revolt. In the Punjab, the tenth Sikh guru transformed his community. In 1699 Guru Gobind Singh founded the Khalsa, an order of initiated Sikhs pledged to a common discipline and to defend the faith with arms. Two of his young sons were later put to death by a Mughal governor.

Too many nobles

Underneath the wars lay a structural problem. To win over Deccani and Maratha leaders, Aurangzeb handed out ranks, and the nobility grew fast. Good jagirs did not. Historians call this shortage of productive jagirs for a growing nobility the jagirdari crisis. Nobles waiting for assignments, or holding poor ones, squeezed peasants harder, lost faith in the system and looked to local alliances. Revenue from the Deccan, much of it ravaged by war, could not pay for the armies sent to win it.

Aurangzeb died in 1707 at Ahmednagar, aged eighty eight. He was buried in a plain open grave at Khuldabad, near the shrine of a Sufi saint, as he had asked.

Worked example: explaining a reign

Was Aurangzeb's religious policy the main cause of the empire's troubles? Test the claim against evidence. If religion drove everything, we would expect Hindu nobles to vanish from the high ranks; in fact their share rose, largely through Maratha recruits. We would expect all Rajputs to revolt, yet Amber stayed loyal while Marwar rebelled over a succession. On the other side, the return of the tax on non-Muslims and the temple destructions gave rebels a cause and alienated many subjects. The likeliest answer combines both: religious policy mattered, but money, land and endless Deccan war mattered at least as much. Testing a single cause against what it predicts is a habit worth keeping.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What was Dara Shikoh's Sirr-i Akbar?
2. Where did Aurangzeb defeat Dara Shikoh in 1658?
3. What was the Fatawa-i Alamgiri?
4. What happened to Shivaji at Agra in 1666?
5. Which sultanates did Aurangzeb conquer in 1686 and 1687?
6. What did Guru Gobind Singh found in 1699?
7. What do historians call the shortage of good jagirs for a growing nobility?
8. Where was Aurangzeb buried?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia