In 1904 the American psychologist G. Stanley Hall published a two-volume study called Adolescence and gave the teenage years a reputation they have never quite shaken. He described adolescence as a time of "storm and stress," borrowing a phrase from German literature. A century of research has kept part of that picture and corrected the rest.
Storm and stress, reconsidered
Hall saw turmoil as a universal, biologically driven stage. Later studies found something more modest. Reviewing the evidence in 1999, Jeffrey Arnett concluded that conflict with parents, swings of mood and risk-taking all rise in adolescence, but that turmoil is more common in adolescence without being universal. Most teenagers get along reasonably well with their parents, and many pass through these years without serious trouble. How stormy adolescence is also varies with culture and with how much independence a society expects young people to claim.
Puberty itself now arrives earlier than it did in the nineteenth century, largely because of better nutrition and health. Its timing relative to peers matters. Studies in several countries find that girls who mature much earlier than their peers face higher risks of depression, early sexual activity and substance use, partly because they draw attention from older adolescents before they are emotionally ready.
Watching oneself
Adolescents gain the ability to think about thinking, including about what others think of them. In 1967 the psychologist David Elkind described two products of this new skill. The imaginary audience is the feeling that everyone is watching and judging you, which can make a pimple feel like front-page news. The personal fable is the belief that one's own experiences are unique, that nobody has ever loved or suffered quite like this, and that bad things happen to other people. Later research suggests both feelings persist into adulthood, though they may be especially intense in the early teens.
Who am I?
The German-born American psychoanalyst Erik Erikson described eight stages across life, each centered on a characteristic tension. For adolescence it was identity versus role confusion: the task of building a coherent sense of who one is and wants to become. In 1966 the psychologist James Marcia turned this into research by asking young people about two things: whether they had explored options in areas such as work, religion and politics, and whether they had committed to any. The answers produced four identity statuses:
- Diffusion: neither exploring nor committed.
- Foreclosure: committed without having explored the options, often by adopting parents' choices.
- Moratorium: actively exploring but not yet committed.
- Achievement: committed after a period of exploration.
The statuses are not fixed stages. A person can be achieved in work and foreclosed in religion, and many people reopen settled questions later in life.
A new stage of life?
In rich countries the traditional markers of adulthood have moved later. In the United States in the mid-1950s the median age at first marriage was about 20 for women and 22 for men; by the 2020s it was about 28 and 30. In 2000 Jeffrey Arnett proposed that the years from about 18 to the mid-twenties, later extended to 29, had become a distinct period he called emerging adulthood. He described it by five features: identity exploration, instability, a focus on oneself, feeling in between adolescence and adulthood, and a sense of open possibilities. Asked whether they had reached adulthood, many young Americans said they had in some ways but not in others. They defined adulthood by taking responsibility for themselves and making their own decisions, along with financial independence, far more than by marriage or parenthood.
Critics raise fair points. The pattern fits young people with money and education far better than others, such as those who must work or raise children early, whether in poorer countries or in poorer families within rich ones. Others argue that the long transition reflects insecure jobs and expensive housing more than a new psychological stage. Arnett has replied that the period takes different forms in different places, but that its core features are spreading as education lengthens around the world.
Worked example: Maya at 23
Maya has changed majors twice, moved back in with her parents after a short job in another city, and cannot decide between nursing and graphic design. Her parents worry she is drifting. Marcia's scheme suggests she is in moratorium in her working life: exploring, not yet committed. That is not the same as diffusion, since she is actively trying things. Her older cousin chose accounting at 17 because his father ran a firm; he is settled, but foreclosed rather than achieved, and may face doubts later. Arnett would see Maya's moves and uncertainty as typical of emerging adulthood, while his critics would ask how much of it reflects the rents in the city where she worked. A useful response from her parents is neither to push her into a quick choice nor to wait passively, but to help her test the options cheaply, for example by shadowing a nurse for a day or taking a short design course, so that her exploration leads somewhere.
