Skip to main content

Children do not choose their parents, their neighborhood or the troubles that land on their household. Developmental research has spent decades asking how much those circumstances matter, and the answer has two sides. Early hardship can cast a long shadow. Yet many children who face it do far better than the statistics would predict, and the reasons why are among the most hopeful findings in psychology.

Parenting styles

In the 1960s the American psychologist Diana Baumrind observed families in California and described parenting along two dimensions: warmth, or responsiveness, and control, or demandingness. Authoritative parents are warm and also set clear, firm expectations, explaining their reasons and listening to the child. Authoritarian parents are demanding but cold, expecting obedience without discussion. Permissive parents are warm but make few demands. In 1983 Eleanor Maccoby and John Martin added a fourth style, neglectful or uninvolved, low on both. In many studies, especially in the United States, authoritative parenting was linked with better school performance, self-reliance and fewer behavior problems.

Three cautions apply. First, the studies are mostly correlational. Second, influence runs both ways. Psychologists use the term child effects for the ways a child's own temperament and behavior shape how parents act: an easygoing child may make authoritative parenting easier, rather than the other way around. Third, the meaning of a style depends on culture. In 1994 Ruth Chao argued that many Chinese American parents looked authoritarian by Baumrind's labels, yet their strictness grew from a tradition of devoted training bound up with closeness and sacrifice, and their children often did well in school.

Adverse childhood experiences

In the 1990s the physician Vincent Felitti and the epidemiologist Robert Anda surveyed more than 17,000 adults, mostly middle-class members of the Kaiser Permanente health plan in San Diego, about events before age 18: abuse, neglect, and household problems such as violence, addiction, mental illness, separation or a jailed family member. Their first major report appeared in 1998. Across the full study, which came to count ten categories, about two thirds reported at least one adverse childhood experience, and about one in eight reported four or more. People with four or more had several times the rates of depression, alcoholism and suicide attempts, and higher rates of heart and lung disease.

The ACE research changed medicine and social work by showing how common childhood adversity is, even in comfortable populations. Researchers also warn against misusing it. The score simply counts categories, treating a parents' divorce and repeated sexual abuse as equal; it relies on adults' memories; and a pattern found in large groups predicts poorly for any one person.

Resilience

Some of the most influential evidence on the other side of the ledger comes from a small Hawaiian island. In 1955 the psychologist Emmy Werner and her colleagues began following all 698 babies born that year on Kauai. About a third were judged at high risk, because of poverty, birth complications, family conflict or a parent's mental illness. Yet about one in three of the high-risk children were doing well by age 18, growing into competent, caring young adults, and by their thirties and forties most of the rest had found their footing too.

What helped? The most consistent protective factor was at least one stable, caring relationship, with a parent, grandparent, older sibling, teacher or neighbor. Others included an easygoing temperament, problem-solving skills, a sense of purpose or faith, and chances to be useful to others. The psychologist Ann Masten, reviewing decades of such work, concluded that resilience is usually not a rare, heroic quality. It grows from ordinary human systems, such as close relationships, a healthy brain and a supportive community, doing what they normally do.

Children as rights holders

These findings feed into law. The United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child, adopted in 1989, treats children not as the property of their parents or objects of charity but as people with rights of their own. These include protection from abuse and from economic exploitation and, in Article 12, a child's right to express views on matters affecting them, with those views given weight according to age and maturity. It is the most widely ratified human rights treaty in the world; the United States has signed it but not ratified it.

Worked example: one steady adult

A primary school teacher notices that nine-year-old Jonah often arrives hungry, has missed several days and flinches when someone raises a voice. She does not need to know his ACE score to act. The research suggests three steps. First, follow the school's procedures for reporting possible harm. Second, become a steady presence: greet him by name, notice what he does well, and keep promises small and reliable. The Kauai study suggests that one such relationship can change a path. Third, give him a way to contribute, such as caring for the class plants, since being needed builds competence and belonging. Treating him as a person whose views count, as Article 12 asks, means telling him honestly what will happen next and listening to what he wants. The aim is not to label Jonah as damaged, but to strengthen the ordinary systems that help children recover.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. How did Baumrind describe authoritative parents?
2. What are child effects?
3. What did Ruth Chao argue about many Chinese American parents?
4. In the ACE research, what share of adults reported at least one adverse experience?
5. What is one warning about using ACE scores?
6. What happened to the high-risk children in Werner's Kauai study?
7. What was the most consistent protective factor in resilience research?
8. What does Article 12 of the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child protect?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia