Skip to main content

The Spanish Inquisition began with a papal bull and a royal choice. It became, within fifteen years, a network of courts with its own council, its own rules and a reputation that frightened even the people who had asked for it.

The bull of 1478

On 1 November 1478 Pope Sixtus IV issued the bull Exigit sinceras devotionis affectus. It allowed Ferdinand and Isabella to name inquisitors and, crucially, to replace them at will. Rome kept a theoretical say but gave up day to day control. The monarchs did not act at once. For about two years the church in Seville tried preaching and instruction instead, and the archbishop of Seville, Cardinal Pedro González de Mendoza, had a simple guide to Christian practice prepared for converts.

In September 1480 the crown appointed two Dominicans, Miguel de Morillo and Juan de San Martín, as the first inquisitors, for Seville. They began work early in 1481. Many conversos fled the city for the lands of great nobles nearby, and the inquisitors ordered the nobles to hand them back. A plot by some leading conversos to resist the tribunal was discovered, though the story of its betrayal comes from later sources and is partly legend. On 6 February 1481 the first auto de fe was held in Seville, and six people were burned. A chronicler of the time, the converso Hernando del Pulgar, criticized the method, arguing that converts raised in ignorance needed teaching more than fire.

The edict of grace

When a tribunal arrived in a new town it usually proclaimed an edict of grace: a period, often thirty to forty days, in which people could confess heresy voluntarily and receive milder penance. The catch was that a full confession had to include the names of others who shared the error. Edicts of grace brought in floods of self denunciations and gave the inquisitors lists of names to pursue. By the sixteenth century they were replaced by edicts of faith, which required everyone to denounce others.

Torquemada and the Suprema

In 1483 the Dominican Tomás de Torquemada, prior of the monastery of Santa Cruz in Segovia, became inquisitor general, at first for Castile and soon for Aragon as well. He was the nephew of a famous cardinal and theologian, Juan de Torquemada, and a contemporary account says that the family had converso ancestors. Torquemada drew up the first general instructions for the tribunals in 1484 and remained in office until his death in 1498. Around the same time the crown created the Council of the Supreme and General Inquisition, known as the Suprema, which supervised every local court. It was one of the royal councils, alongside those for Castile, Aragon and finance, and it was the only institution whose authority ran in every one of the monarchs' kingdoms.

Resistance in Aragon

Aragon had its own laws and liberties, and many there saw the new court as an attack on them. In April 1482 Sixtus IV issued a bull complaining that the Aragonese inquisitors were acting from greed rather than zeal and ordering fairer procedures. Ferdinand replied with a furious letter, and the pope suspended his own bull. In Zaragoza the resistance turned violent. On the night of 15 September 1485 the inquisitor Pedro de Arbués was stabbed while praying in the cathedral of Zaragoza and died two days later. The killers were tied to prominent converso families. Public outrage destroyed the opposition, the plotters were hunted down, and Arbués was later venerated as a martyr.

The La Guardia case

In 1490 and 1491 the Inquisition tried a group of conversos and Jews from the area of La Guardia, near Toledo, for supposedly crucifying a Christian child and using his heart in sorcery. No child was ever identified as missing, and the confessions were obtained under torture and contradicted each other. The accused were burned at Ávila in November 1491. The case was publicized widely just months before the decision to expel the Jews, and it shows how a tribunal could turn rumor into apparent proof.

Worked example: reading the numbers of the first decades

How many people did the early Inquisition kill? Hernando del Pulgar wrote that around two thousand people had been burned in the archdiocese of Seville by about 1490, with many more reconciled. Later historians have used figures like this to suggest that the first fifty years, roughly 1480 to 1530, were the bloodiest in the tribunal's history, with perhaps two thousand executions in all, though some scholars give higher numbers.

Treat such figures with care. Pulgar was a witness but not a statistician, and the records of several early tribunals, including Seville, are largely lost. Historians therefore combine chronicles, surviving trial summaries and lists of sambenitos once hung in churches. A sensible reading is that the early decades were far more violent than later ones and fell overwhelmingly on conversos, while any exact total remains an estimate. Notice also what drove the violence: a new court, judges eager to prove its worth, edicts of grace that multiplied names, and a crown that profited from confiscations. Institutions can create the very caseload they claim merely to discover.

Quiz

5 questions · Practice: scored, not saved

1. What did the bull Exigit sinceras devotionis affectus allow?
2. Who were the first inquisitors appointed for Seville in 1480?
3. What happened at the first auto de fe, held in Seville in February 1481?
4. What was an edict of grace?
5. What did Tomás de Torquemada draw up in 1484?
6. What was the Suprema?
7. What happened to the inquisitor Pedro de Arbués in 1485?
8. What was striking about the La Guardia case of 1490 to 1491?

CivilSimian.com created by AxiomaticPanic, CivilSimian, Kalokagathia